VALIDITY OF AGROECOSYSTEM MODELS - A COMPARISON OF RESULTS OF DIFFERENT MODELS APPLIED TO THE SAME DATA SET

被引：171

作者：

DIEKKRUGER, B ^{[1
]}

SONDGERATH, D ^{[1
]}

KERSEBAUM, KC ^{[1
]}

MCVOY, CW ^{[1
]}

机构：

[1] ZENTRUM AGRARLANDSCHAFTS & LANDNUTZUNGSFORSCH,D-15374 MUNCHEBERG,GERMANY

来源：

ECOLOGICAL MODELLING | 1995年 / 81卷 / 1-3期

关键词：

AGRICULTURAL ECOSYSTEMS; VALIDATION;

D O I：

10.1016/0304-3800(94)00157-D

中图分类号：

Q14 [生态学（生物生态学）];

学科分类号：

071012 ; 0713 ;

摘要：

The simulation results obtained from 19 participants of the workshop ''Validation of Agroecosystem Models'' were compared and discussed. Although all models were applied to the same data set, the results differ significantly. From the results it can be concluded that the experience of a scientist applying a model is as important as the differences between various model approaches. Only one model simulated all main processes like water dynamics, plant growth and nitrogen dynamics with the same quality, the others are able to reproduce the measured dynamic only in parts.

引用

页码：3 / 29

页数：27

共 22 条

[1]

[Anonymous], 1982, BASIC MICROCOMPUTER

[2] VALIDATION - AN OBJECTIVE OR A TOOL - RESULTS ON A WINTER-WHEAT SIMULATION-MODEL APPLICATION [J].

BACSI, Z ;

ZEMANKOVICS, F .

ECOLOGICAL MODELLING, 1995, 81 (1-3) :251-263

[3] SIMULATION OF WATER AND NITROGEN FLOWS AND PLANT-GROWTH FOR A WINTER-WHEAT STAND IN CENTRAL GERMANY [J].

BLOMBACK, K ;

STAHLI, M ;

ECKERSTEN, H .

ECOLOGICAL MODELLING, 1995, 81 (1-3) :157-167

[4] THE USERS INFLUENCE ON MODEL CALIBRATION RESULTS - AN EXAMPLE OF THE MODEL SOIL, INDEPENDENTLY CALIBRATED BY 2 USERS [J].

BOTTERWEG, P .

ECOLOGICAL MODELLING, 1995, 81 (1-3) :71-81

[5] A DYNAMIC-MODEL DESCRIBING LEAF TEMPERATURE AND TRANSPIRATION OF WHEAT PLANTS [J].

CLAUS, S ;

WERNECKE, P ;

PIGLA, U ;

DUBSKY, G .

ECOLOGICAL MODELLING, 1995, 81 (1-3) :31-40

[6]

DEWILLIGEN P, 1991, FERT RES, V27, P141, DOI 10.1007/BF01051122

[7] MODELING PESTICIDE DYNAMICS OF A LOAM SITE USING HERBSIM AND SIMULAT [J].

DIEKKRUGER, B ;

NORTERSHEUSER, P ;

RICHTER, O .

ECOLOGICAL MODELLING, 1995, 81 (1-3) :111-119

[8] SIMULATION OF WATER FLUXES USING DIFFERENT METHODS FOR ESTIMATING SOIL PARAMETERS [J].

DIEKKRUGER, B ;

ARNING, M .

ECOLOGICAL MODELLING, 1995, 81 (1-3) :83-95

[9] SIMULATION OF TEMPERATURE, WATER AND NITROGEN DYNAMICS USING THE MODEL CANDY [J].

FRANKO, U ;

OELSCHLAGEL, B ;

SCHENK, S .

ECOLOGICAL MODELLING, 1995, 81 (1-3) :213-222

[10] DYNAMICS OF ENERGY, WATER, CARBON AND NITROGEN IN AGRICULTURAL ECOSYSTEMS - SIMULATION AND EXPERIMENTAL VALIDATION [J].

GRANT, RF .

ECOLOGICAL MODELLING, 1995, 81 (1-3) :169-181

← 1 2 3 →