Psychosomatic or somatopsychotic? A critical analysis of psychosomatic Medicine

被引:0
|
作者
Sandler, Paulo Cesar [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Sao Paulo, Fac Saude Publ, Med, Sao Paulo, SP, Brazil
来源
EINSTEIN-SAO PAULO | 2008年 / 6卷 / 02期
关键词
Psychosomatic Medicine; Psychoanalysis; Health knowledge; attitudes; practice;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Objective: To assess the scientific foundations of the so-called "psychosomatic Medicine" underlying all medical and scientific concepts and statements, likewise in any science. Case reports are presented. Methods: The following issues were epistemologically tested: (i) the mind causes bodily diseases; (ii) depression causes cancer; (iii) stress causes myocardial infarction and other diseases and (iv) body language. In order to study the statements and propositions, the author used: (i) theories from the Enlightenment period; (ii) positivist theories and (iii) modern science theories. All these theories are presented briefly. Results: There is evidence of a spurious split between body and mind, which results in one-sided investigations - without questioning their actual existence. This split is also shown by the psychosomatic Medicine, which has added some additional problems to the field. Conclusions: Results of epistemological and psychoanalytic "assessments" enable a critical analysis of the psychosomatic model, without apparently being successful in presenting a holistic approach, and requiring alternatives. Recommended medical management of "psychosomatic patients" is also presented.
引用
收藏
页码:134 / 141
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [41] Psychosomatic medicine
    Kamphusmann, B
    ZEITSCHRIFT FUR KLINISCHE PSYCHOLOGIE PSYCHIATRIE UND PSYCHOTHERAPIE, 1999, 47 (04): : 416 - 419
  • [42] Psychosomatic Medicine
    Begre, Stefan
    THERAPEUTISCHE UMSCHAU, 2019, 76 (05) : 229 - 229
  • [43] PSYCHOSOMATIC MEDICINE .1. PSYCHOSOMATIC APPROACH
    MUNRO, A
    PRACTITIONER, 1972, 208 (1243) : 162 - &
  • [44] Core Competencies for Fellowship Training in Psychosomatic Medicine: A Collaborative Effort by the APA Council on Psychosomatic Medicine, the ABPN Psychosomatic Committee, and The Academy of Psychosomatic Medicine
    Worley, Linda L. M.
    Levenson, James L.
    Stern, Theodore A.
    Epstein, Steven A.
    Rundell, James R.
    Crone, Catherine C.
    Wise, Thomas N.
    Rummans, Teresa A.
    Muskin, Philip R.
    Bourgeois, James A.
    Saravay, Stephen M.
    Pao, Maryland
    Alter, Carol
    Steinberg, Maurice
    Wulsin, Lawson
    Breitbart, William
    Fricchione, Gregory L.
    Boland, Robert
    Epstein, Lucy A.
    Winstead, Daniel
    Gitlin, David F.
    PSYCHOSOMATICS, 2009, 50 (06) : 557 - 562
  • [45] Mediation Analysis in Psychosomatic Medicine Research
    Lockhart, Ginger
    MacKinnon, David P.
    Ohlrich, Vanessa
    PSYCHOSOMATIC MEDICINE, 2011, 73 (01): : 29 - 43
  • [46] Core Competencies for Fellowship Training in Psychosomatic Medicine: A Collaborative Effort by the APA Council on Psychosomatic Medicine, the ABPN Psychosomatic Committee, and The Academy of Psychosomatic Medicine Response
    Gitlin, David F.
    Worley, Linda L. M.
    PSYCHOSOMATICS, 2011, 52 (02) : 196 - 197
  • [47] ORIGINS OF PSYCHOSOMATIC-MEDICINE AND AMERICAN PSYCHOSOMATIC SOCIETY
    LIDDELL, HS
    PSYCHOSOMATIC MEDICINE, 1962, 24 (01): : 10 - &
  • [48] PSYCHOSOMATIC MEDICINE .5. PSYCHOSOMATIC ASPECTS OF HYPERTENSION
    MACCULLO.MJ
    PRACTITIONER, 1972, 208 (1247) : 704 - &
  • [49] PSYCHOSOMATIC MEDICINE .3. PSYCHOSOMATIC ASPECTS OF ASTHMA
    PINKERTON, P
    PRACTITIONER, 1972, 208 (1245) : 430 - +
  • [50] PSYCHOSOMATIC MEDICINE .10. PSYCHOSOMATIC ASPECTS OF EPILEPSY
    BETTS, TA
    PRACTITIONER, 1972, 209 (1252) : 574 - &