CONDITIONS UNDER WHICH A BOGUS PIPELINE PROCEDURE ENHANCES THE VALIDITY OF SELF-REPORTED CIGARETTE-SMOKING - A META-ANALYTIC REVIEW

被引:49
作者
AGUINIS, H
PIERCE, CA
QUIGLEY, BM
机构
[1] University at Albany, State University of New York
关键词
D O I
10.1111/j.1559-1816.1993.tb01092.x
中图分类号
B84 [心理学];
学科分类号
04 ; 0402 ;
摘要
A meta-analysis was conducted to test whether the use of self-report measures within the bogus pipeline (BPL) paradigm yields more valid responses than the use of self-report measures alone for assessing cigarette smoking behavior. The meta-analytic results indicate that, overall, a BPL condition resulted in a larger proportion of subjects reporting that they are frequent smokers, as compared to a self-report measure only (no pipeline) condition. Tests of categorical models indicate that the enhanced validity of self-reports within the BPL paradigm is moderated by the following variables: (a) type of BPL presentation employed, (b) type of self-report measure to which the BPL technique is compared, and (c) whether most participants are smokers (as indicated by a biochemical marker).
引用
收藏
页码:352 / 373
页数:22
相关论文
共 71 条
[1]  
ABRAMS DB, IN PRESS ANN REV ADD
[2]  
AKERS RL, 1983, SOC FORCES, V62, P234
[3]  
Arkin R.M., 1981, IMPRESSION MANAGEMEN, P311
[4]   VALIDITY OF SELF-REPORTS OF ADOLESCENT CIGARETTE-SMOKING [J].
BAUMAN, KE ;
KOCH, GG ;
BRYAN, ES .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF THE ADDICTIONS, 1982, 17 (07) :1131-1136
[5]   INFLUENCE OF AN OBJECTIVE-MEASURE ON SELF-REPORTS OF BEHAVIOR [J].
BAUMAN, KE ;
DENT, CW .
JOURNAL OF APPLIED PSYCHOLOGY, 1982, 67 (05) :623-628
[6]   EFFECTS OF COGNITIVE DISSONANCE ON INAPPROPRIATE EMOTIONAL REACTIONS [J].
BEHAR, LB .
JOURNAL OF PERSONALITY, 1967, 35 (03) :505-&
[7]   NOTES ON CONTAMINATION METHOD - 2 SMALL EXPERIMENTS IN ASSURING CONFIDENTIALITY OF RESPONSES [J].
BERMAN, J ;
MCCOMBS, H ;
BORUCH, R .
SOCIOLOGICAL METHODS & RESEARCH, 1977, 6 (01) :45-62
[8]   ADOLESCENTS SELF-REPORTS OF TOBACCO, ALCOHOL, AND MARIJUANA USE - EXAMINING THE COMPARABILITY OF VIDEO TAPE, CARTOON AND VERBAL BOGUS-PIPELINE PROCEDURES [J].
BOTVIN, EM ;
BOTVIN, GJ ;
RENICK, NL ;
FILAZZOLA, AD ;
ALLEGRANTE, JP .
PSYCHOLOGICAL REPORTS, 1984, 55 (02) :379-386
[9]  
BRAMEL D, 1962, J ABNORM PSYCHOL, V64, P121
[10]  
Cacioppo J.T., 1981, ATTITUDES PERSUASION