Experimental and numerical studies have shown similarities between localized turbulence in channel and pipe flows. By scaling analysis of a disturbed-flow model, this paper proposes a local Reynolds number Re-M to characterize the threshold of transition triggered by finite-amplitude disturbances. The ReM represents the maximum contribution of the basic flow to the momentum ratio between the nonlinear convection and the viscous diffusion. The lower critical ReM observed in experiments of plane Poiseuille flow, pipe Poiseuille flow and plane Couette flow are all close to 323, indicating the uniformity of mechanism governing the transition to localized turbulence. (C) 2011 The Chinese Society of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics.