William Wardell's 1859 St John's College: "A rare realisation of Pugin's ideal Catholic College"?

William Wardell's St John's College, Sydney, considered the grandest and most distinguished university college in New South Wales, is an exceptional example of nineteenth century Gothic Revival architecture. The information board outside the college states that St John's is 'a rare realisation of Pugin's ideal Catholic College' and that 'it demonstrates [Pugin]'s profound influence on the work of Wardell'. This is but a small part of the story. The commission for St John's College was far more complex. The correspondence between the architects, William Wardell, Edmund Blacket and others, and St John's Council indicates that right from the beginning there was a general lack of understanding of Wardell's original design concept for the building. This has continued to the present day, as evidenced by the information board outside St John's College, in which it is incorrectly assumed that Wardell's proposal included a quadrangle as featured in Pugin's 'ideal College'. This paper, based largely on primary sources, investigates such claims, considers William Wardell and the Gothic Revival, examines St John's College within the University of Sydney - its design and its translation - and posits a few conclusions that lead to new understandings of the building.