Arguing with a Monument: Frederick Douglass' Resolution of the 'White Man Problem' in his 'Oration in Memory of Lincoln'

This revisionist view applies an 'interracial turn' lens to Frederick Douglass' 1876 Freedmen's Monument Speech, in which he critiqued the myth of Lincoln as 'the liberator.' After sketching interracial dynamics in Douglass ante bellum career, I do a close reading of visual rhetoric in this oration. Read through a history of Douglass' complex but ultimately fecund relationships with white men, the speech constitutes a performative resolution of Douglass' 'white man problem,' I argue. A historically situated reading of Douglass' rhetoric reveals the maturity of his political thought, which calls on future audiences to reassess Douglass' identity, and legacy. A 'revised Douglass' charted a path by which the United States could revise its own 'white male problem.' Douglass' model is timely, given recurring episodes of interracial violence, and the social and rhetorical unrest they spark. As a figure who battled racialism and lived a 'more attractive alternative,' Douglass provides deep legitimation for an 'interracial turn' in fields including American Studies, communication, ethnography, rhetorical studies, and literary criticism.