ASTROPHYSICAL SOLUTIONS ARE INCOMPATIBLE WITH THE SOLAR-NEUTRINO DATA

被引:135
作者
HATA, N
BLUDMAN, S
LANGACKER, P
机构
[1] Department of Physics, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia
来源
PHYSICAL REVIEW D | 1994年 / 49卷 / 07期
关键词
D O I
10.1103/PhysRevD.49.3622
中图分类号
P1 [天文学];
学科分类号
0704 ;
摘要
We consider the most general solar model, using the neutrino fluxes as free parameters constrained only by the solar luminosity, and show that the combined solar neutrino data exclude any astrophysical solution at 97% C.L. Our best fit to the Be-7 and B-8 fluxes is, respectively, < 8% and 37+/-4% of the standard solar model prediction, but only with a large chi2 (4.8 for 1 DF). This best fit to the fluxes contradicts explicit nonstandard solar models, which generally reduce the B-8 flux more than the Be-7. Those models are well parametrized by a single parameter, the central temperature.
引用
收藏
页码:3622 / 3625
页数:4
相关论文
共 40 条
  • [1] SEARCH FOR NEUTRINOS FROM THE SUN USING THE REACTION GA-71(NU-E,E-)GE-71
    ABAZOV, AI
    ANOSOV, OL
    FAIZOV, EL
    GAVRIN, VN
    KALIKHOV, AV
    KNODEL, TV
    KNYSHENKO, II
    KORNOUKHOV, VN
    MEZENTSEVA, SA
    MIRMOV, IN
    OSTRINSKY, AV
    PSHUKOV, AM
    REVZIN, NE
    SHIKHIN, AA
    TIMOFEYEV, PV
    VERETENKIN, EP
    VERMUL, VM
    ZATSEPIN, GT
    BOWLES, TJ
    CLEVELAND, BT
    ELLIOTT, SR
    OBRIEN, HA
    WARK, DL
    WILKERSON, JF
    DAVIS, R
    LANDE, K
    CHERRY, ML
    KOUZES, RT
    [J]. PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS, 1991, 67 (24) : 3332 - 3335
  • [2] IMPLICATIONS OF THE GALLEX DETERMINATION OF THE SOLAR NEUTRINO FLUX
    ANSELMANN, P
    HAMPEL, W
    HEUSSER, G
    KIKO, J
    KIRSTEN, T
    PERNICKA, E
    PLAGA, R
    RONN, U
    SANN, M
    SCHLOSSER, C
    WINK, R
    WOJCIK, M
    VONAMMON, R
    EBERT, KH
    HENRICH, E
    BALATA, M
    BELLOTTI, E
    FERRARI, N
    LALLA, H
    STOLARCZYK, T
    CATTADORI, C
    CREMONESI, O
    FIORINI, E
    PEZZONI, S
    ZANOTTI, L
    VONFEILITZSCH, F
    MOSSBAUER, R
    SCHANDA, U
    BERTHOMIEU, G
    SCHATZMAN, E
    CARMI, I
    DOSTROVSKY, I
    BACCI, C
    BELLI, P
    BERNABEI, R
    DANGELO, S
    PAOLUZI, L
    CHARBIT, S
    CRIBIER, M
    DUPONT, G
    GOSSET, L
    RICH, J
    SPIRO, M
    TAO, C
    VIGNAUD, D
    HAHN, RL
    HARTMANN, FX
    ROWLEY, JK
    STOENNER, RW
    WENESER, J
    [J]. PHYSICS LETTERS B, 1992, 285 (04) : 390 - 397
  • [3] SOLAR NEUTRINOS OBSERVED BY GALLEX AT GRAN SASSO
    ANSELMANN, P
    HAMPEL, W
    HEUSSER, G
    KIKO, J
    KIRSTEN, T
    PERNICKA, E
    PLAGA, R
    RONN, U
    SANN, M
    SCHLOSSER, C
    WINK, R
    WOJCIK, M
    VONAMMON, R
    EBERT, KH
    FRITSCH, T
    HELLRIEGEL, K
    HENRICH, E
    STIEGLITZ, L
    WEYRICH, F
    BALATA, M
    BELLOTTI, E
    FERRARI, N
    LALLA, H
    STOLARCZYK, T
    CATTADORI, C
    CREMONESI, O
    FIORINI, E
    PEZZONI, S
    ZANOTTI, L
    VONFEILITZSCH, F
    MOSSBAUER, R
    SCHANDA, U
    BERTHOMIEU, G
    SCHATZMAN, E
    CARMI, I
    DOSTROVSKY, I
    BACCI, C
    BELLI, P
    BERNABEI, R
    DANGELO, S
    PAOLUZI, L
    CHARBIT, S
    CRIBIER, M
    DUPONT, G
    GOSSET, L
    RICH, J
    SPIRO, M
    TAO, C
    VIGNAUD, D
    HAHN, RL
    [J]. PHYSICS LETTERS B, 1992, 285 (04) : 376 - 389
  • [4] GALLEX SOLAR-NEUTRINO OBSERVATIONS - THE RESULTS FROM GALLEX-I AND EARLY RESULTS FROM GALLEX-II
    ANSELMANN, P
    HAMPEL, W
    HEUSSER, G
    KIKO, J
    KIRSTEN, T
    LAUBENSTEIN, M
    PERNICKA, E
    PEZZONI, S
    PLAGA, R
    RONN, U
    SANN, M
    SCHLOSSER, C
    WINK, R
    WOJCIK, M
    VONAMMON, R
    EBERT, KH
    FRITSCH, T
    HELLRIEGEL, K
    HENRICH, E
    STIEGLITZ, L
    WEYRICH, F
    BALATA, M
    FERRARI, N
    LALLA, H
    BELLOTTI, E
    CATTADORI, C
    CREMONESI, O
    FIORINI, E
    ZANOTTI, L
    ALTMANN, M
    VONFEILITZSCH, F
    MOSSBAUERZ, R
    SCHANDA, U
    BERTHOMIEU, G
    SCHATZMAN, E
    CARMI, I
    DOSTROVSKY, I
    BACCI, C
    BELLI, P
    BERNABEI, R
    DANGELO, S
    PAOLUZI, L
    CHARBIT, S
    CRIBIER, M
    DUPONT, G
    GOSSET, L
    RICH, J
    SPIRO, M
    STOLARCZYK, T
    TAO, C
    [J]. PHYSICS LETTERS B, 1993, 314 (3-4) : 445 - 458
  • [5] Bahcall J.N., 1989, NEUTRINO ASTROPHYSIC
  • [6] CHLORINE AND GALLIUM SOLAR NEUTRINO EXPERIMENTS
    BAHCALL, JN
    CLEVELAND, BT
    DAVIS, R
    ROWLEY, JK
    [J]. ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1985, 292 (02) : L79 - L82
  • [7] SOLAR MODELS, NEUTRINO EXPERIMENTS, AND HELIOSEISMOLOGY
    BAHCALL, JN
    ULRICH, RK
    [J]. REVIEWS OF MODERN PHYSICS, 1988, 60 (02) : 297 - 372
  • [8] SHAPES OF SOLAR-NEUTRINO SPECTRA - UNCONVENTIONAL TESTS OF THE STANDARD ELECTROWEAK MODEL
    BAHCALL, JN
    [J]. PHYSICAL REVIEW D, 1991, 44 (06): : 1644 - 1651
  • [9] STANDARD SOLAR MODELS, WITH AND WITHOUT HELIUM DIFFUSION, AND THE SOLAR NEUTRINO PROBLEM
    BAHCALL, JN
    PINSONNEAULT, MH
    [J]. REVIEWS OF MODERN PHYSICS, 1992, 64 (04) : 885 - 926
  • [10] MATTER-ENHANCED NEUTRINO OSCILLATIONS IN THE STANDARD SOLAR MODEL
    BAHCALL, JN
    HAXTON, WC
    [J]. PHYSICAL REVIEW D, 1989, 40 (04): : 931 - 941