A CONTINUOUS QUALITY IMPROVEMENT PROJECT TO IMPROVE THE QUALITY OF CERVICAL PAPANICOLAOU SMEARS

Objective: To improve the quality of cervical Papanicolaou smears by continuous quality improvement techniques. Methods: The study used a Papanicolaou smear data base of over 200,000 specimens collected between June 1988 and December 1992. A team approach employing techniques such as process now-charting, cause and effect diagrams, run charts, and a randomized trial of collection methods was used to evaluate potential causes of Papanicolaou smear reports with the notation ''inadequate'' or ''less than optimal'' due to too few or absent endocervical cells. Once a key process variable (method of collection) was identified, the proportion of Papanicolaou smears with inadequate or absent endocervical cells was determined before and after employment of a collection technique using a spatula and Cytobrush. We measured the rate of less than optimal Papanicolaou smears due to too few or absent endocervical cells. Results: Before implementing the new collection technique fully by June 1990, the overall rate of less than optimal cervical Papanicolaou smears ranged from 20-25%; by December 1993, it had stabilized at about 10%. Conclusion: Continuous quality improvement can be used successfully to study a clinical process and implement change that will lead to improvement.