RANDOMIZED TRIAL OF LOBECTOMY VERSUS LIMITED RESECTION FOR T1 N0 NON-SMALL-CELL LUNG-CANCER

被引:1679
|
作者
HOLMES, CE [1 ]
RUCKDESCHEL, JC [1 ]
JOHNSTON, M [1 ]
THOMAS, PA [1 ]
DESLAURIERS, J [1 ]
GROVER, FL [1 ]
HILL, LD [1 ]
FELD, R [1 ]
GINSBERG, RJ [1 ]
MOUNTAIN, CF [1 ]
DZUIBAN, S [1 ]
KIELY, M [1 ]
MCKNEALLY, MF [1 ]
MOORES, DWO [1 ]
RAMNES, C [1 ]
WAGNER, H [1 ]
BUNN, P [1 ]
CHU, H [1 ]
DIENHART, D [1 ]
HAZUKA, M [1 ]
KINZIE, J [1 ]
SORENSEN, J [1 ]
VANCE, V [1 ]
BRAUN, T [1 ]
HOPEMAN, A [1 ]
KANE, M [1 ]
RUSS, P [1 ]
WHITMAN, GJR [1 ]
FALL, SM [1 ]
HANSEN, DP [1 ]
HENDERSON, RH [1 ]
MONCRIEF, CL [1 ]
PAULING, F [1 ]
SIMS, J [1 ]
TELL, D [1 ]
WISELYCARR, S [1 ]
ABERNATHY, CM [1 ]
CLARK, DA [1 ]
MCCROSKEY, B [1 ]
MOORE, G [1 ]
MOORE, F [1 ]
MYERS, A [1 ]
WHITE, M [1 ]
BROOKS, RJ [1 ]
BULL, M [1 ]
JOHNSON, FB [1 ]
NEIMYR, M [1 ]
PAQUETTE, FR [1 ]
SACCOMANNO, G [1 ]
LAD, T [1 ]
机构
[1] MEM SLOAN KETTERING CANC CTR, DEPT SURG, THORAC SERV, NEW YORK, NY 10021 USA
来源
ANNALS OF THORACIC SURGERY | 1995年 / 60卷 / 03期
关键词
D O I
10.1016/0003-4975(95)00537-u
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Background. It has been reported that limited resection (segment or wedge) is equivalent to lobectomy in the management of early stage (T1-2 NO) non-small cell lung cancer. Methods. A prospective, multiinstitutional randomized trial was instituted comparing limited resection with lobectomy for patients with peripheral TI NO non-small cell lung cancer documented at operation. Analysis included locoregional and distant recurrence rates, 5-year survival rates, perioperative morbidity and mortality, and late pulmonary function assessment. Results. There were 276 patients randomized, with 247 patients eligible for analysis. There were no significant differences for all stratification variables, selected prognostic factors, perioperative morbidity, mortality, or late pulmonary function. In patients undergoing limited resection, there was an observed 75% increase in recurrence rates (p = 0.02, one-sided) attributable to an observed tripling of the local recurrence rate (p = 0.008 two-sided), an observed 30% increase in overall death rate (p = 0.08, one-sided), and an observed 50% increase in death with cancer rate (p = 0.09, one-sided) compared to patients undergoing lobectomy (p = 0.10, one-sided was the predefined threshold for statistical significance for this equivalency study). Conclusions. Compared with lobectomy, limited pulmonary resection does not confer improved perioperative morbidity, mortality, or late postoperative pulmonary function. Because of the higher death rate and locoregional recurrence rate associated with limited resection, lobectomy still must be considered the surgical procedure of choice for patients with peripheral T1 NO nonsmall cell lung cancer.
引用
收藏
页码:615 / 622
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] RANDOMIZED TRIAL OF LOBECTOMY VERSUS LIMITED RESECTION FOR T1 N0 NON-SMALL-CELL LUNG-CANCER - INVITED COMMENTARY
    PETERS, RM
    ANNALS OF THORACIC SURGERY, 1995, 60 (03): : 622 - 623
  • [2] Lobectomy versus limited resection in T1 N0 lung cancer
    Lederle, FA
    ANNALS OF THORACIC SURGERY, 1996, 62 (04): : 1249 - 1249
  • [3] Wedge resection versus lobectomy for stage I (T1 N0 M0) non-small-cell lung cancer
    Landreneau, RJ
    Sugarbaker, DJ
    Mack, MJ
    Hazelrigg, SR
    Luketich, JD
    Fetterman, L
    Liptay, MJ
    Bartley, S
    Boley, TM
    Keenan, RJ
    Ferson, PF
    Weyant, RJ
    Naunheim, KS
    JOURNAL OF THORACIC AND CARDIOVASCULAR SURGERY, 1997, 113 (04): : 691 - 700
  • [4] CANCER RECURRENCE AFTER RESECTION - T1 N0 NON-SMALL CELL LUNG-CANCER
    THOMAS, P
    RUBINSTEIN, L
    ANNALS OF THORACIC SURGERY, 1990, 49 (02): : 242 - 247
  • [5] MALIGNANT DISEASE APPEARING LATE AFTER OPERATION FOR T1 N0 NON-SMALL-CELL LUNG-CANCER
    THOMAS, PA
    HOLMES, EC
    PIANTADOSI, S
    RUCKDESCHEL, JC
    DESLAURIERS, J
    GROVER, FL
    HILL, LD
    FELD, R
    GINSBERG, R
    MOUNTAIN, C
    EAGAN, R
    JOURNAL OF THORACIC AND CARDIOVASCULAR SURGERY, 1993, 106 (06): : 1053 - 1058
  • [6] Intentional limited resection for selected patients with T1 N0 M0 non-small-cell lung cancer: A single-institution study
    Kodama, K
    Doi, O
    Higashiyama, M
    Yokouchi, H
    JOURNAL OF THORACIC AND CARDIOVASCULAR SURGERY, 1997, 114 (03): : 347 - 353
  • [7] The Role of Sublobar Resection in T1 N0 Non-Small-Cell Pulmonary Carcinoma
    Yaldiz, Demet
    Yakut, Funda Cansun
    Kaya, Seyda Ors
    Gursoy, Soner
    Yaldiz, Mehmet Sadik
    TURKISH THORACIC JOURNAL, 2020, 21 (05): : 308 - 313
  • [8] Lobectomy Versus Limited Resection in T1N0 Lung Cancer
    Detterbeck, Frank C.
    ANNALS OF THORACIC SURGERY, 2013, 96 (02): : 742 - 744
  • [9] SURVIVAL AFTER CONSERVATIVE RESECTION FOR T1-N0-M0 NON-SMALL-CELL LUNG-CANCER
    READ, RC
    YODER, G
    SCHAEFFER, RC
    ANNALS OF THORACIC SURGERY, 1990, 49 (03): : 391 - 400
  • [10] RADICAL LASER SEGMENTECTOMY FOR T1 N0 LUNG-CANCER
    KODAMA, K
    DOI, O
    YASUDA, T
    HIGASHIYAMA, M
    YOKOUCHI, H
    ANNALS OF THORACIC SURGERY, 1992, 54 (06): : 1193 - 1195