The "Ground Zero mosque": sacred space and the boundaries of American identity

For much of 2010, plans to develop a multipurpose Islamic center near the site of the 9/11 attacks in Lower Manhattan occasioned an intense nationwide debate. In this study of the "Ground Zero mosque" controversy, we focus on questions of identity and the sacred in the contemporary USA. We argue that the response to the "Ground Zero mosque" illuminates three important phenomena. First, it reveals the dynamics of cultural guardianship among those who opposed Park51, an effort to "preserve" a national identity tightly linked with Christianity (and antithetical to Islam). Second, as illustrated by the rights-based response by defenders of the project, we suggest that the language of liberalism may be insufficient to address a more expansive and complex understanding of the relationship between religion and political identity. And third, the controversy highlights the challenges that remain in the post-9/11 USA for American Muslims, many of whom understood the proposed center as their own, rather conventional, attempt to join the American mainstream.