LIMITS ON THE HUBBLE CONSTANT FROM THE HST DISTANCE OF M100

被引:57
作者
MOULD, J
HUCHRA, JP
BRESOLIN, F
FERRARESE, L
FORD, HC
FREEDMAN, WL
GRAHAM, J
HARDING, P
HILL, R
HOESSEL, JG
HUGHES, SM
ILLINGWORTH, GD
KELSON, D
KENNICUTT, RC
MADORE, BF
PHELPS, R
STETSON, PB
TURNER, A
机构
[1] HARVARD SMITHSONIAN CTR ASTROPHYS,CAMBRIDGE,MA 02138
[2] UNIV ARIZONA,STEWARD OBSERV,TUCSON,AZ 85721
[3] JOHNS HOPKINS UNIV,BALTIMORE,MD 21218
[4] SPACE TELESCOPE SCI INST,BALTIMORE,MD 21218
[5] CARNEGIE INST WASHINGTON,PASADENA,CA 91101
[6] DEPT TERR MAGNETISM,WASHINGTON,DC 20015
[7] UNIV WISCONSIN,MADISON,WI 53706
[8] ROYAL GREENWICH OBSERV,CAMBRIDGE CB3 0HA,ENGLAND
[9] UNIV CALIF SANTA CRUZ,LICK OBSERV,SANTA CRUZ,CA 95064
[10] CALTECH,CTR INFRARED PROC & ANAL,PASADENA,CA 91125
[11] NATL RES COUNCIL CANADA,DOMINION ASTROPHYS OBSERV,HERZBERG INST ASTROPHYS,VICTORIA,BC V8X 4M6,CANADA
关键词
DISTANCE SCALE; GALAXIES; CLUSTERS; INDIVIDUAL; (VIRGO); DISTANCES AND REDSHIFTS; (M100); SUPERNOVAE; GENERAL;
D O I
10.1086/176066
中图分类号
P1 [天文学];
学科分类号
0704 ;
摘要
Because M100 is in the Virgo cluster, our recent measurement of its distance has an impact on the calibration of all of the extragalactic secondary distance indicators which reach beyond Virgo and define the expansion rate. We examine the consequences of a 17 Mpc M100 distance, questioning its consistency with supernova and other distances. The distance of M100 provides two separate constraints on the Hubble constant. First, it verifies the emissivity calculations for Type II supernovae. These models, fitted to SN 1987A, have recently been used to measure host galaxy distances beyond 10(4) km s-l recession velocity. Second, it constrains the distance of the Virgo cluster, which in spite of its apparent complex structure, provides an effective calibration for a set of reliable and well-used secondary distance indicators. Reviewing the Type II supernova distances for three galaxies with Cepheid distances, we find consistency, which supports the recent SN result H-0 = 73 +/- 11 km s(-1) Mpc(-1). This support is independent of where M100 lies in the Virgo cluster. Reviewing the Hubble recession velocity (cosmological redshift) of the Virgo cluster, we find H-0 = 81 +/- 11 km s(-1) Mpc(-1), plus an additional uncertainty arising from the extended nature of the Virgo cluster. Employing the Virgo cluster as calibrator, we obtain measurements of the Hubble constant from extant surface brightness fluctuation measurements, elliptical galaxy velocity dispersion measurements, the Tully-Fisher relation, and the Type Ia supernova standard candle. These yield H-0 = 84 +/- 16, 76 +/- 10, 82 +/- 11, and 71 +/- 10 km s(-1) Mpc(-1), respectively. All of these are consistent, but they are all subject to the additional uncertainty from Virgo's line-of-sight depth. We explore a number of simple models of the structure of the Virgo cluster; these support the recent conclusion of Freedman and coworkers that the appropriate uncertainty to attach to the Hubble constant from the Cepheid distance to Virgo is 20%. A value of H-0 = 80 +/- 17 km s(-1) Mpc(-1) is consistent with all the data discussed herein. Confidence limits with 95% significance can be assigned to the interval 50 < H-0 < 100 km s(-1) Mpc(-1). Further work in this program should be expected to identify the systematic differences between the distance indicators investigated here and constrain the Hubble constant to 10% accuracy.
引用
收藏
页码:413 / 421
页数:9
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] The extragalactic distance scale key project .4. The discovery of Cepheids and a new distance to M100 using the Hubble space telescope
    Ferrarese, L
    Freedman, WL
    Hill, RJ
    Saha, A
    Madore, BF
    Kennicutt, RC
    Stetson, PB
    Ford, HC
    Graham, JA
    Hoessel, JG
    Han, MS
    Huchra, J
    Hughes, SM
    Illingworth, GD
    Kelson, D
    Mould, JR
    Phelps, R
    Silbermann, NA
    Sakai, S
    Turner, A
    Harding, P
    Bresolin, F
    ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1996, 464 (02) : 568 - &
  • [2] The Hubble Constant and HST
    Tammann, G. A.
    Sandage, A.
    IMPACT OF HST ON EUROPEAN ASTRONOMY, 2010, : 289 - +
  • [3] The Cepheid distance to M96 and the Hubble constant
    Tanvir, NR
    Ferguson, HC
    Shanks, T
    MONTHLY NOTICES OF THE ROYAL ASTRONOMICAL SOCIETY, 1999, 310 (01) : 175 - 188
  • [4] Distance ladders and the Hubble constant crisis
    Chen, Xiaodian
    Wang, Shu
    SCIENTIA SINICA-PHYSICA MECHANICA & ASTRONOMICA, 2024, 54 (11)
  • [5] 1ST HUBBLE-SPACE-TELESCOPE OBSERVATIONS OF THE BRIGHTEST STARS IN THE VIRGO GALAXY M100=NGC-4321
    FREEDMAN, WL
    MADORE, BF
    STETSON, PB
    HUGHES, SMG
    HOLTZMAN, JA
    MOULD, JR
    TRAUGER, JT
    GALLAGHER, JS
    BALLESTER, GE
    BURROWS, CJ
    CASERTANO, S
    CLARKE, JT
    CRISP, D
    FERRARESE, L
    FORD, H
    GRAHAM, JA
    GRIFFITHS, RE
    HESTER, JJ
    HILL, R
    HOESSEL, JG
    HUCHRA, J
    KENNICUTT, RC
    SCOWEN, PA
    SPARKS, B
    STAPELFELDT, KR
    WATSON, AM
    WESTPHAL, J
    ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1994, 435 (01) : L31 - &
  • [6] STEPS TOWARD THE HUBBLE CONSTANT .10. THE DISTANCE OF THE VIRGO CLUSTER CORE USING GLOBULAR-CLUSTERS
    SANDAGE, A
    TAMMANN, GA
    ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1995, 446 (01) : 1 - 11
  • [7] THE CENTRAL REGION IN M100 - OBSERVATIONS AND MODELING
    KNAPEN, JH
    BECKMAN, JE
    HELLER, CH
    SHLOSMAN, I
    DEJONG, RS
    ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1995, 454 (02) : 623 - +
  • [8] Measurement of Hubble constant: were differences in secondary distance indicators apparent as early as the HST Key Project?
    Thakur, Rahul Kumar
    Gupta, Shashikant
    Nigam, Rahul
    Thiruvikraman, P. K.
    RESEARCH IN ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS, 2021, 21 (03)
  • [9] Discovery of a nova in the Virgo galaxy M100
    Ferrarese, L
    Livio, M
    Freedman, W
    Saha, A
    Stetson, PB
    Ford, HC
    Hill, RJ
    Madore, BF
    ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 1996, 468 (02) : L95 - &
  • [10] A REDETERMINATION OF THE HUBBLE CONSTANT WITH THE HUBBLE SPACE TELESCOPE FROM A DIFFERENTIAL DISTANCE LADDER
    Riess, Adam G.
    Macri, Lucas
    Casertano, Stefano
    Sosey, Megan
    Lampeitl, Hubert
    Ferguson, Henry C.
    Filippenko, Alexei V.
    Jha, Saurabh W.
    Li, Weidong
    Chornock, Ryan
    Sarkar, Devdeep
    ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 2009, 699 (01) : 539 - 563