What is critical hermeneutics?

被引:22
作者
Roberge, Jonathan [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Quebec Montreal, Chaire Rech Canada Mondialisat Citoyennete & Demo, 8888 Succursale Ctr Ville, Montreal, PQ H3C 3P8, Canada
关键词
action; critical theory; experience; hermeneutics; ideology; meaning; Paul Ricoeur;
D O I
10.1177/0725513611411682
中图分类号
C91 [社会学];
学科分类号
030301 ; 1204 ;
摘要
This article explores the promises of critical hermeneutics as an innovative method and philosophy within the human sciences. It is argued that its success depends on its ability to articulate a theory of meaning with one of action and experience as well as its capacity to renew our understanding of the problem of ideology. First, critical hermeneutics must explain how cultural messages 'show and hide'; that is, how the ambiguity of meaning always allows for a group to represent itself while opening the door for distortion and domination. Second, critical hermeneutics ought to show how action can be best understood as opposing performances driven by ideological-moral views. Through an analysis of social movements, for instance, it is shown that any attempt to do justice could also and easily create exclusion. Third, critical hermeneutics has to clarify how tension and dualism within meaning and action are not to be dissociated from the self-interpretation of concrete individuals. A theory of experience is thus required in order to explain why the autonomy of the subject is finally at stake with regard to the problem of ideology.
引用
收藏
页码:5 / 22
页数:18
相关论文
共 50 条
[31]   Self and other in global bioethics: critical hermeneutics and the example of different death concepts [J].
Zeiler, Kristin .
MEDICINE HEALTH CARE AND PHILOSOPHY, 2009, 12 (02) :137-145
[32]   What happened to the fig tree? An empirical study in psychological type and biblical hermeneutics [J].
Francis, Leslie J. .
MENTAL HEALTH RELIGION & CULTURE, 2012, 15 (09) :873-891
[33]   The question of the "subject" in hermeneutics gadamerienne [J].
Deniau, Guy .
METHODOS-SAVOIRS ET TEXTES, 2005, (05)
[34]   Problems of Studying Babylonian Hermeneutics [J].
Emelianov, Vladimir V. .
VOPROSY FILOSOFII, 2017, (08) :155-165
[35]   HERMENEUTICS OF THE SENSE OF "SOCIAL THINGS" [J].
Beltran Villalva, Miguel .
ARBOR-CIENCIA PENSAMIENTO Y CULTURA, 2013, 189 (761)
[36]   Writing, hermeneutics, and corpus linguistics [J].
Teubert, Wolfgang .
REVISTA SIGNOS, 2007, 40 (64) :431-453
[37]   De-coding Hermeneutics [J].
Adam, A. K. M. .
HORIZONS IN BIBLICAL THEOLOGY, 2019, 41 (02) :127-161
[38]   Religiosity as Desired Stimulation in the Hermeneutics [J].
Vodicar, Janez .
PERSON AND THE CHALLENGES-THE JOURNAL OF THEOLOGY EDUCATION CANON LAW AND SOCIAL STUDIES INSPIRED BY POPE JOHN PAUL II, 2011, 1 (01) :127-150
[39]   HERMENEUTICS OF TRANSLATION AND UNDERSTANDING OF VIOLENCE [J].
Borisov, Sergey N. ;
Rimsky, Viktor P. .
PHILOSOPHY AND SOCIETY-FILOZOFIJA I DRUSTVO, 2020, 31 (02) :165-176
[40]   What is Orthodox Critical Theory? [J].
Freyenhagen, Fabian .
DEUTSCHE ZEITSCHRIFT FUR PHILOSOPHIE, 2017, 65 (03) :456-469