Intermolecular electron transfer and geminate recombination are explored experimentally in both solid and liquid solutions using the same donor-acceptor pair. The solvents were chosen to have similar chemical and dielectric properties, but vastly different viscosities. Systems of an electron donor, rubrene, and varying concentrations of an electron acceptor, duroquinone, were studied. The solvents used were diethyl sebacate (liquid) and sucrose octaacetate (solid). Forward electron transfer was studied using time-resolved and steady-state fluorescence measurements for a variety of acceptor concentrations. Electron back-transfer (geminate recombination) was measured using pump-probe experiments. The data were analyzed using a theoretical treatment that takes into account diffusion of the donor and acceptors, a distance-dependent (exponential) transfer rate, Coulomb interactions between the ions generated by the forward transfer, and donor-acceptor and acceptor-acceptor excluded volumes. The forward transfer data, in both the solid and liquid solutions, are in very good agreement with calculations. Virtually identical forward transfer parameters are obtained from the solid and liquid samples. The back-transfer parameters obtained from the measurements on solid solution are able to reproduce the liquid solution's back-transfer data, but only when the high-frequency dielectric constant is used. The use of this value for the dielectric constant is discussed.