RECOVERY FROM MISANALYSES OF GARDEN-PATH SENTENCES

被引:165
作者
FERREIRA, F
HENDERSON, JM
机构
[1] University of Alberta, Edmonton
基金
加拿大自然科学与工程研究理事会;
关键词
D O I
10.1016/0749-596X(91)90034-H
中图分类号
H0 [语言学];
学科分类号
030303 ; 0501 ; 050102 ;
摘要
In five experiments we examined the way in which readers reanalyze garden-path sentences, using grammaticality judgments as the dependent measure. The stimuli were twoclause sentences containing an ambiguous noun phrase which could function as either the object of the first clause or the subject of the second. Prior research has shown that the former analysis is generally preferred. In the first two experiments, we varied the number of words in the ambiguous phrase and found that reanalysis of garden-path sentences was more difficult with a longer ambiguous phrase. The third experiment established that this effect of phrase length is not attributable to the greater syntactic complexity of longer phrases. The fourth and fifth experiments demonstrated that the effect of phrase length is attributable to increasing the distance from the head of the ambiguous phrase to the disambiguating word of the graden-path sentence: Ambiguous phrases made long by the addition of prenominal adjectives were easy for the parser to reanalyze, but phrases made long by the addition of postnominal modifying prepositional phrases (Experiment 3) or relative clauses (Experiments 4 and 5) were hard for the parser to reanalyze. From these results, we argue that sentence comprehension requires the creation of phrase structure and the assignment of thematic roles to phrases, with the assignment taking place at the phrasal head. Reanalysis is affected by the ease with which thematic roles can be reassigned to misanalyzed phrases. © 1991.
引用
收藏
页码:725 / 745
页数:21
相关论文
共 22 条
[1]  
ALTMANN GTM, 1989, LANG COGNITIVE PROC, V4, P1
[2]   Ambiguity in Context [J].
Clifton, Charles, Jr. ;
Ferreira, Fernanda .
LANGUAGE AND COGNITIVE PROCESSES, 1989, 4 (3-4) :SI77-SI103
[3]   THE INDEPENDENCE OF SYNTACTIC PROCESSING [J].
FERREIRA, F ;
CLIFTON, C .
JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND LANGUAGE, 1986, 25 (03) :348-368
[4]   EFFECTS OF LENGTH AND SYNTACTIC COMPLEXITY ON INITIATION TIMES FOR PREPARED UTTERANCES [J].
FERREIRA, F .
JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND LANGUAGE, 1991, 30 (02) :210-233
[5]  
Ferreira F., 1991, UNDERSTANDING WORD S, P305
[6]  
Frazier L., 1987, ATTENTION PERFORMANC
[7]  
Frazier Lyn, 1978, THESIS U CONNECTICUT
[8]   LEXICAL EXPECTATIONS IN PARSING COMPLEMENT-VERB SENTENCES [J].
HOLMES, VM ;
STOWE, L ;
CUPPLES, L .
JOURNAL OF MEMORY AND LANGUAGE, 1989, 28 (06) :668-689
[9]   PARADIGMS AND PROCESSES IN READING-COMPREHENSION [J].
JUST, MA ;
CARPENTER, PA ;
WOOLLEY, JD .
JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-GENERAL, 1982, 111 (02) :228-238
[10]   INSPECTION TIMES FOR WORDS IN SYNTACTICALLY AMBIGUOUS SENTENCES UNDER 3 PRESENTATION CONDITIONS [J].
KENNEDY, A ;
MURRAY, WS .
JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-HUMAN PERCEPTION AND PERFORMANCE, 1984, 10 (06) :833-849