Revisiting Phenomenal Intentionality

This essay has two goals. The goal of the first section is to raise a few clarificatory questions about the exact contour of Crane's account of intentionality, its relation to phenomenology, and his motivation for it. The second section aims to describe a general worry about programs that combine a broadly anti-externalist outlook on intentionality with the idea that there is an intimate connection between phenomenology and intentionality. I argue that programs like this either suffer from a problem that I call intentional luck or, in the attempt to avoid this problem, have to weaken the connection between intentionality and phenomenology. Since Crane's general outlook falls under this program, it is subject to this worry.