SELF-FIELD QUANTUM ELECTRODYNAMICS - THE 2-LEVEL ATOM - COMMENT

被引：4

作者：

CRISP, MD

机构：

[1] Silver Spring, MD 20910

来源：

PHYSICAL REVIEW A | 1991年 / 43卷 / 07期

关键词：

D O I：

10.1103/PhysRevA.43.4058

中图分类号：

O43 [光学];

学科分类号：

070207 ; 0803 ;

摘要：

Barut and Dowling [Phys. Rev. A 41, 2284 (1990)] have raised questions concerning the "illegal use" of superposition in the neoclassical radiation theory of Crisp and Jaynes [Phys. Rev. 179, 1253 (1969)]. They also continue to use an expansion for their wave function that has been questioned as to its validity and interpretations [Bialynicki-Birula, Phys. Rev. A 34, 3500 (1986)]. Both of these points will be discussed in this Comment.

引用

收藏

页码：4058 / 4059

页数：2

相关论文

共 13 条

[1] RADIATION REACTION AND RADIATIVE FREQUENCY-SHIFTS [J].

ACKERHALT, JR ;

KNIGHT, PL ;

EBERLY, JH .

PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS, 1973, 30 (10) :456-460

[2] QUANTUM ELECTRODYNAMICS AND RADIATION REACTION - NONRELATIVISTIC ATOMIC FREQUENCY-SHIFTS AND LIFETIMES [J].

ACKERHALT, JR ;

EBERLY, JH .

PHYSICAL REVIEW D, 1974, 10 (10) :3350-3375

[3] QUANTUM ELECTRODYNAMICS BASED ON SELF-ENERGY VERSUS QUANTIZATION OF FIELDS - ILLUSTRATION BY A SIMPLE-MODEL [J].

BARUT, AO .

PHYSICAL REVIEW A, 1986, 34 (04) :3502-3503

[4] QUANTUM ELECTRODYNAMICS BASED ON SELF-FIELDS, WITHOUT 2ND QUANTIZATION - A NONRELATIVISTIC CALCULATION OF G-2 [J].

BARUT, AO ;

DOWLING, JP ;

VANHUELE, JF .

PHYSICAL REVIEW A, 1988, 38 (09) :4405-4412

[5]

BARUT AO, 1989, Z NATURFORSCH A, V44, P1051

[6] RELATIVISTIC THEORY OF SPONTANEOUS EMISSION [J].

BARUT, AO ;

SALAMIN, YI .

PHYSICAL REVIEW A, 1988, 37 (07) :2284-2296

[7] SELF-FIELD QUANTUM ELECTRODYNAMICS - THE 2-LEVEL ATOM [J].

BARUT, AO ;

DOWLING, JP .

PHYSICAL REVIEW A, 1990, 41 (05) :2284-2294

[8] NONPERTURBATIVE QUANTUM ELECTRODYNAMICS - THE LAMB SHIFT [J].

BARUT, AO ;

KRAUS, J .

FOUNDATIONS OF PHYSICS, 1983, 13 (02) :189-194

[9] QUANTUM ELECTRODYNAMICS BASED ON SELF-ENERGY - LAMB SHIFT AND SPONTANEOUS EMISSION WITHOUT FIELD QUANTIZATION [J].

BARUT, AO ;

VANHUELE, JF .

PHYSICAL REVIEW A, 1985, 32 (06) :3187-3195

[10] QUANTUM ELECTRODYNAMICS BASED ON SELF-ENERGY - LAMB SHIFT AND SPONTANEOUS EMISSION WITHOUT FIELD QUANTIZATION - COMMENT [J].

BIALYNICKIBIRULA, I .

PHYSICAL REVIEW A, 1986, 34 (04) :3500-3501