ASSOCIATIVE RELATION UNDERLYING AUTOSHAPING IN PIGEON

Pigeons (15) were exposed to either response-independent or response-dependent schedules of water reinforcement, whereby water was injected directly into the unrestrained pigeons'' mandibles. Key-contact responses were released by a lighted key correlated with water, but not by a lighted key uncorrelated with water. A negative response-reinforcer contingency suppressed autoshaped key-contact responses, resulting in responding directed away from the lighted key. In all pigeons, water injected directly into the mandibles elicited a consummatory fixed-action pattern of mumbling and swallowing. The lighted key correlated with water released a broader set of both appetitive and consummatory responses: approach to the lighted key, bowing, rooting, mumbling and swallowing. Key-contact responses were rooting and mumbling motions of the beak on the surface of the key. Views of autoshaping based on stimulus substitution or stimulus surrogation do not fully explain the origin of autoshaped responses not previously elicited by the reinforcer. The present findings are consonant with views of conditioning that emphasize the large degree of biological pre-organization in conditioned response patterns, and the importance of associative factors in the control of such patterns.