Revelation and physicalism

被引:0
作者
Kelly Trogdon
机构
[1] Virginia Tech,Department of Philosophy
来源
Synthese | 2017年 / 194卷
关键词
Phenomenal concepts; Phenomenal properties; Physicalism; Revelation; Essence; The phenomenal concept strategy;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
学科分类号
摘要
According to experiential revelation, phenomenal concepts reveal the nature of the phenomenal properties they refer to. Some see experiential revelation as posing a direct challenge to physicalism. The basic idea is this: given experiential revelation, were phenomenal properties physical/functional in nature they would be presented as such when you think of them under phenomenal concepts, but phenomenal concepts don’t present their referents in this way. I argue that, while this argument on a plausible reconstruction fails, the thesis of experiential revelation nevertheless indirectly challenges physicalism. In particular, it potentially undermines the so-called phenomenal concept strategy, a key defense maneuver of the physicalist for responding to dualist arguments concerning experience. The moral is that issues concerning revelation do indeed pose a problem for physicalism, but not for the reasons you might think.
引用
收藏
页码:2345 / 2366
页数:21
相关论文
共 9 条
[1]  
Balog K(2012)In defense of the phenomenal concept strategy Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 84 1-23
[2]  
Block N(1986)Advertisement for a semantics for psychology Midwest Studies in Philosophy 10 615-678
[3]  
Dasgupta S(2014)The possibility of physicalism Journal of Philosophy 111 557-592
[4]  
Diaz-Leon E(2010)Can phenomenal concepts explain the epistemic gap? Mind 119 933-951
[5]  
Diaz-Leon E(2014)Do a posteriori physicalists get our phenomenal concepts wrong? Ratio 27 1-16
[6]  
Fine K(1994)Essence and modality Philosophical Perspectives 8 1-16
[7]  
Goff P(2011)A posteriori physicalists get our phenomenal concepts wrong Australasian Journal of Philosophy 89 191-209
[8]  
Levin J(2002)Is conceptual analysis needed for the reduction of qualitative states? Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 64 571-591
[9]  
Schroer R(2010)Where’s the beef? Phenomenal concepts as both demonstrative and substantial The Australasian Journal of Philosophy 88 505-522