Intracavitary brachytherapy for carcinoma of the uterine cervix: Comparison of HDR (Ir-192) and MDR (Cs-137)

Purpose: To compare the results of high dose rate (HDR) (Ir-192) and medium dose rate (MDR) (Cs-137) intracavitary brachytherapy (ICRT) for carcinoma of the uterine cervix. Materials and Methods: Between May 1991 and March 2001, a total of 206 patients with Stage I-IVA previously untreated cervical cancer were treated with ICRT combined with external beam radiotherapy (EBRT). HDR was administered to a total of 135 patients: 22 patients in Stage I, 49 in Stage II, 56 in Stage III, and eight in Stage IVA. MDR was administered to a total of 71 patients: six patients in Stage I, 27 in Stage II, 33 in Stage III, and five in Stage IVA. The MDR at point A was 30 Gy/hour for HDR and 1.7 Gy/hour for MDR treatment, and the corresponding median follow-up periods for survivors were 55 and 68 months. Results: For the HDR group, 5-year cause-specific survival rates were 90%, 78%, 53% and 33% for Stages I, II, III, and IVA, respectively. For the MDR group, the corresponding rates were 100%, 76%, 51%, and 40%. In the HDR group, 19 patients (14%) developed Grade 2 or higher late complications, and, in the MDR group, four patients (6%) did. Conclusions: There was no statistically significant difference in cause-specific survivals between the results of HDR and MDR brachytherapy for cervical cancer. The incidence of late complications tended to be higher for the HDR group than for the MDR group, but did not show a statistically significant difference (p=0.07).