Immunohistochemical determination of her2 expression in breast cancer from core biopsy specimens: a reliable predictor of her2 status of the whole tumor

HER2 overexpression in breast cancer is associated with a poor prognosis, resistance to endocrine therapy and chemosensitivity to anthracyclines and paclitaxel. Moreover, trastuzumab (HerceptinR) shows therapeutic benefit in patients with HER2 overexpressing tumors. Therefore, knowledge of the pretherapeutical HER2 status allows an optimal selection of patients for treatment. In addition to a definitive histological diagnosis, core biopsies of tumors offer the opportunity to evaluate the HER2 status preoperatively. In 64 patients with invasive breast cancer, sections of core biopsies and of the subsequently removed whole tumor were investigated immuno-histochemically with the DAKO HercepTestTM. Fifteen tumors (23%) revealed HER2 overexpression, and 44 tumors (69%) were negative in both, the core biopsy and the whole tumor sections. Two core biopsies were negative whereas the corresponding final specimen was 2+ positive. In 3 cases weak overexpression was observed in the core biopsy, but the whole tumor was negative. The overall concordance of the results achieved at core biopsy and whole tumor sections was 92% κ=0.8). A negative HER2 result on core biopsy was never associated with a score 3+ tumor specimen nor was there a case of negative whole tumor specimen with a preceding 3+ score in the biopsy. If one demands the highest degree of overexpression (3+), 100% of our study patients would have been selected correctly using the results on core biopsy alone. We thus conclude, that the immunohistochemical investigation of core biopsies offers the opportunity for a valid preoperative estimation of HER2 overexpression.