Relating Wikipedia article quality to edit behavior and link structure

被引:0
作者
Thorsten Ruprechter
Tiago Santos
Denis Helic
机构
[1] Institute of Interactive Systems and Data Science,
[2] Graz University of Technology,undefined
来源
Applied Network Science | / 5卷
关键词
Wikipedia; Edit behavior; Link structure; Article quality; Edit wars; Controversy; Conflict; Semantic edit types;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
学科分类号
摘要
Currently, the relation between edit behavior, link structure, and article quality is not well-understood in our community, notwithstanding that this relationship may facilitate editing processes and content quality on Wikipedia. To shed light on this complex relation, we classify article edits and perform an in-depth analysis of editing sequences for 4941 articles. Additionally, we build a network of internal Wikipedia hyperlinks between articles. Using this data, we compute parsimonious metrics to quantify editing and linking behavior. Our analysis unveils that conflicted articles differ substantially from others in almost all metrics, while we also detect slight trends for high-quality articles. With our network analysis we find evidence indicating that controversial and edit war articles frequently span structural holes in the Wikipedia network. Finally, in a prediction experiment we demonstrate the usefulness of edit behavior patterns and network properties in predicting conflict and article quality. With our work, we assist online collaboration communities, especially Wikipedia, in long-term improvement of content quality by offering valuable insights about the interplay of article quality, controversies and edit wars, editing behavior, and network properties via sequence-based edit and network-based article metrics.
引用
收藏
相关论文
共 59 条
  • [1] Albert R(2002)Statistical mechanics of complex networks Rev Mod Phys 74 47-98
  • [2] Barabási A-L(2011)Information quality in wikipedia: the effects of group composition and task conflict J Manag Inf Syst 27 71-177
  • [3] Arazy O(2001)A faster algorithm for betweenness centrality J Math Sociol 25 163-56
  • [4] Nov O(2001)Structural holes versus network closure as social capital Soc Capital Theory Res 1 30-13122
  • [5] Patterson R(2017)You can’t stay here: the efficacy of reddit’s 2015 ban examined through hate speech HCI 1 31-414
  • [6] Yeo L(2006)Britannica attacks Nature 440 582-1380
  • [7] Brandes U(1981)Analyzing revision Coll Compos Commun 32 400-619
  • [8] Burt RS(2014)The dynamic nature of conflict in Wikipedia EPL 108 18003-25
  • [9] Chandrasekharan E(2004)Patterns of link reciprocity in directed networks Phys Rev Lett 93 268701-93
  • [10] Pavalanathan U(1973)The strength of weak ties Am J Socioly 78 1360-336