Enduring and Perduring Objects in Minkowski Space-Time

被引:0
作者
Yuri Balashov
机构
来源
Philosophical Studies | 2000年 / 99卷
关键词
Special Theory; Plausible Account; Relativistic Framework; Single Moment; Central Endurantist;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
学科分类号
摘要
I examine the issue of persistence over time in thecontext of the special theory of relativity (SR). Thefour-dimensional ontology of perduring objects isclearly favored by SR. But it is a different questionif and to what extent this ontology is required, andthe rival endurantist ontology ruled out, by thistheory. In addressing this question, I take theessential idea of endurantism, that objects are whollypresent at single moments of time, and argue that itcommits one to unacceptable conclusions regardingcoexistence, in the context of SR. I then propose anddiscuss a plausible account of coexistence forperduring objects, which is free of these defects. This leaves the endurantist room for some maneuvers. I consider them and show that they do not really helpthe endurantist out. She can accommodate the notionof coexistence in the relativistic framework only atthe cost of renouncing central endurantist intuitions.
引用
收藏
页码:129 / 166
页数:37
相关论文
共 19 条
[1]  
Carter W.R.(1994)On Passage and Persistence American Philosophical Quarterly 31 269-283
[2]  
Hestevold H.S.(1995)The Definability of Objective Becoming in Minkowski Spacetime Synthese 103 355-387
[3]  
Clifton R.(1996)On Becoming, Relativity, and Nonseparability Philosophy of Science 63 585-604
[4]  
Hogarth M.(1989)Endurance and Temporary Intrinsics Analysis 49 119-125
[5]  
Dorato M.(1989)Persistence, Change, and Explanation Philosophical Studies 56 1-28
[6]  
Haslanger S.(1987)Is There A Problem About Persistence? Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society Supplement61 107-135
[7]  
Haslanger S.(1994)The 3D/4D Controversy and Non-Present Objects Philosophical Papers 23 243-49
[8]  
Johnston M.(1985)Are Probabilism and Special Relativity Incompatible? Philosophy of Science 52 23-43
[9]  
Markosian N.(1994)Endurance and Indiscernibility Journal of Philosophy 91 165-184
[10]  
Maxwell N.(1995)On the Incompatibility of Enduring and Perduring Entities Mind 104 523-531