An Error Criterion in Digital Image Correlation for Unknown Deformation Fields and Its Application of Parameters Selection

Digital image correlation (DIC) is a widely used optical metrology for surface deformation measurement. In DIC, the square root of the mean square error (RMS error) and standard deviation error (SD error) are used as quantitative criteria in order to evaluate the accuracy and robustness of a DIC method\algorithm. However, RMS and SD error criteria are computed from prescribed and measured displacements, which indicates that the prescribed displacement fields must be precisely generated. Therefore, it is difficult to quantitatively evaluate the accuracy and robustness of an algorithm\method in practical DIC measurements because imposed displacements are unknown (that’s why DIC measurements are needed). Moreover, the accuracy of DIC measurements highly relies on parameters selection, especially the selections of subset size and shape function. In practice, the subset size and shape function are usually selected according to experience because there are numerous factors (e.g. the quality of speckle image, local displacement field) and uncertainties (e.g. noise level, out-of-plane motion, illumination lighting fluctuation during image capturing) that affect the parameters selection, which makes it difficult to select optimal parameters based on previous works which mainly focused on theoretical deduction in ideal condition. In this paper, an error criterion for evaluating the accuracy of practical DIC measurements with unknown displacements is proposed. Numerical experiments are used to validate the effectiveness and feasibility of the proposed criterion for accuracy evaluation. It is concluded that the square root of the sum of squared forward and backward displacements difference (SFBD) error has a significant positive linear correlation with the widely used SD error in most practical DIC measurements where the mismatch between the frequently-used first- and second-order shape functions and the actual field is usually small. Also, an application of the proposed criterion is presented by real experiments for subset size and shape function selections, which verifies that the proposed error criterion can be effectively used for DIC parameters selection.