Comparison of startup and anaerobic wastewater treatment in UASB, hybrid and baffled reactor

An experimental study was carried out to compare the performance of selected anaerobic high rate reactors operated simultaneously at 37 °C. The three reactors, namely upflow anaerobic sludge bed reactor (UASB), hybrid of UASB reactor and anaerobic filter (anaerobic hybrid reactor – AHR) and anaerobic baffled reactor (ABR), were inoculated with the anaerobic digested sludge from municipal wastewater treatment plant and tested with synthetic wastewater. This wastewater contained sodium acetate and glucose with balanced nutrients and trace elements (COD 6000 mg · l−1). Organic loading rate (Bv) was increased gradually from an initial 0.5 kg · m−3 · d−1 to 15 kg · m−3 · d−1 in all the reactors. From the comparison of the reactors' performance, the lowest biomass wash-out resulted from ABR. In the UASB, significant biomass wash-out was observed at the Bv 6 kg · m−3 · d−1, and in the AHR at the Bv 12 kg · m−3 · d−1. The demand of sodium bicarbonate for pH maintenance in ABR was two times higher as for UASB and AHR. The efficiency of COD removal was comparable for all three reactors – 80–90%. A faster biomass granulation was observed in the ABR than in the other two reactors. This fact is explained by the kinetic selection of filamentous bacteria of the Methanotrix sp. under a high (over 1.5 g · l−1) acetate concentration.