Media framing of the Cape Town water crisis: perspectives on the food-energy-water nexus

被引:0
作者
J. Leah Jones
Dave D. White
Djiby Thiam
机构
[1] Arizona State University,School of Sustainability
[2] Arizona State University,School of Community Resources and Development
[3] University of Cape Town,School of Economics
来源
Regional Environmental Change | 2022年 / 22卷
关键词
Food-energy-water nexus; Media framing; Framing theory; South Africa; Water management;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
学科分类号
摘要
The 2018 water crisis in Cape Town, South Africa, captured the attention of international media outlets as the city faced the possibility of running out of water. Examining this media provides an opportunity to understand the framing of the water crisis, which can provide valuable insights into what society and policymakers consider important. Media analysis can also examine the framing of the impacts of the crisis; with strong interlinkages between food, energy, and water resources, the water crisis directly impacted other resource sectors. To explore the media perspective on the crisis and its impacts across the food and energy sectors, the research here uses content analysis to analyze news articles about the water crisis. We analyze the framing of the problems and solutions to the water crisis and the framing of food-energy-water nexus interactions and impacts. Our results show that the media framed the water crisis as being caused by drought, politics, poor management, and overuse of water, while it presented the proposed solutions of reducing demand and increasing water supply through technological solutions. Additionally, the media framing shows a major impact of the water crisis on the agriculture sector and a strong reliance on energy-intensive technical solutions to address the water crisis, suggesting potential unintended consequences within the food and energy sectors without direct consideration of their intersections. We conclude that the media framing may suggest a mismatch between causes and solutions, as the media rarely presented improving governance and management as potential solutions, yet identified poor governance as a cause of the crisis.
引用
收藏
相关论文
共 88 条
[1]  
Albrecht TR(2018)The water-energy-food nexus : a systematic review of methods for nexus assessment Environ Res Lett 13 1-26
[2]  
Crootof A(2002)Agenda setting and the “New” news Communic Res 29 180-207
[3]  
Scott CA(2008)Collaborative governance in theory and practice J Public Adm Res Theory 18 543-571
[4]  
Althaus SL(2015)Food and green space in cities: a resilience lens on gardens and urban environmental movements Urban Stud 52 1321-1338
[5]  
Tewksbury D(2000)Framing processes and social movements: an overview and assessment Annu Rev Sociol 26 611-639
[6]  
Ansell C(1996)Natural disasters as focusing events: policy communities and political response Int J Mass Emerg Disasters 14 221-243
[7]  
Gash A(2014)Framing environmental problems: problem entrepreneurs and the issue of water pollution from agriculture in Brittany, 1970–2005 J Environ Policy Plan 16 21-35
[8]  
Barthel S(2017)Urban metabolism: a review with reference to Cape Town Cities 70 91-110
[9]  
Parker J(2012)An integrative framework for collaborative governance J Public Adm Res Theory 22 1-29
[10]  
Ernstson H(2014)The nexus of food, energy, and water J Agric Food Chem 62 6255-6262