Incommensurability and theory comparison in experimental biology

被引：0
作者：
Marcel Weber
机构：
[1] University of Hanover,Center for Philosophy and Ethics of Science
来源：
Biology and Philosophy | 2002年 / 17卷
关键词：
Experimental Biology; Scientific Theory; Empirical Comparison; Theory Comparison; Incommensurable Theory;
D O I：
暂无
中图分类号：
学科分类号：
摘要：
Incommensurability of scientific theories, as conceived by Thomas Kuhnand Paul Feyerabend, is thought to be a major or even insurmountable obstacletothe empirical comparison of these theories. I examine this problem in light ofaconcrete case from the history of experimental biology, namely the oxidativephosphorylation controversy in biochemistry (ca. 1961-1977). After a briefhistorical exposition, I show that the two main competing theories which werethe subject of the ox-phos controversy instantiate some of the characteristicfeatures of incommensurable theories, namely translation failure,non-corresponding predictions, and different claims about what kinds ofentitiesexist in the world. By examining how the controversy was eventually resolved, Ithen show that at least this pair of incommensurable theories couldneverthelessbe empirically compared.
引用
收藏
页码：155 / 169
页数：14
相关论文
共 34 条
[1]  
Allchin D.(1997)A Twentieth-Century Phlogiston: Constructing Error and Differentiating Domains Persp. Sci. 5 81-127
[2]  
Andersen H.(1996)Categorization, Anomalies and the Discovery of Nuclear Fission Studies Hist. Phil. Modern Ph. 27 463-492
[3]  
Boyer P.D.(1977)Oxidative Phosphorylation and Photophosphorylation Ann. Rev. Bioch. 46 955-1026
[4]  
Chance B.(1995)Two Letters of Paul Feyerabend to Thomas S. Kuhn on a Draft of The Structure of Scientific Revolutions Studies Hist. Phil. Sci. 26 353-387
[5]  
Ernster L.(1966)Partial Resolution of the Enzymes Catalyzing Oxidative Phosphorylation. X. Correlation of Morphology and Function in Sumitochondrial Particles ATP Formation Caused by Acid-base Transition of Spinach Chloroplasts Proceedings of the National Academy of Science USA 55 170-177
[6]  
Mitchell P.(1966)Partial Resolution of The Enzymes Catalyzing Oxidative Phosophorylation XXV. Reconstitution of Vesicles Catalyzing J. Biol. Chem. 241 2475-2482
[7]  
Racker E.(1971)P J. Biol. Chem. 246 5477-5487
[8]  
Slater E.C.(1961)-Adenosine Triphosphate Exchange Nature 191 144-148
[9]  
Hoyningen-Huene P.(1965)Coupling of Phosphorylation to Electron and Hydrogen Transfer by a Chemiosmotic Type of Mechanism Nature 208 147-151
[10]  
Jagendorf A.T.(1952)Stoichiometry of Proton Translocation through the Respiratory Chain and Adenosine Triphosphatase Systems of Rat Liver Mitochondria J. Biol. Chem. 198 731-743
1234