Conditionals are material: the positive arguments

被引:0
作者
Adam Rieger
机构
[1] University of Glasgow,School of Humanities
来源
Synthese | 2013年 / 190卷
关键词
Indicative conditionals; Truth-functionality; Material conditional;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
学科分类号
摘要
A number of papers have argued in favour of the material account of indicative conditionals, but typically they either concentrate on defending the account from the charge that it has counterintuitive consequences, or else focus on some particular positive argument in favour of the theory. In this paper, I survey the various positive arguments that can be given, presenting simple versions where possible and showing the connections between them. I conclude with some methodological considerations.
引用
收藏
页码:3161 / 3174
页数:13
相关论文
共 12 条
  • [1] Ajdukiewicz K.(1956)Conditional sentence and material implication Studia Logica 4 135-153
  • [2] Barker S.(1997)Material implication and general indicative conditionals The Philosophical Quarterly 47 195-211
  • [3] Clark M.(1971)Ifs and hooks Analysis 32 33-39
  • [4] Clark M.(1974)Ifs and hooks: A rejoinder Analysis 34 77-83
  • [5] Edgington D.(1986)Do conditionals have truth conditions Crítica: Revista Hispanoamericana de Filosofía 18 3-39
  • [6] Hanson W. H.(1991)Indicative conditionals are truth-functional Mind 100 53-72
  • [7] Lewis C.(1894)A logical paradox Mind 3 436-438
  • [8] Pendlebury M.(1989)The projection strategy and the truth conditions of conditional statements Mind 98 179-205
  • [9] Rieger A.(2006)A simple theory of conditionals Analysis 66 233-240
  • [10] Vann M.(1985)A counterexample to modus ponens Journal of Philosophy 82 462-471