Exposure to tax dilemmas deteriorate individuals' self-declared tax morale

被引:0
作者
Emmanuelle Deglaire
Peter Daly
Fabrice Le Lec
机构
[1] EDHEC Business School,
[2] University of Lille,undefined
来源
Economics of Governance | 2021年 / 22卷
关键词
Tax ethics; Tax avoidance; Tax dilemma; Tax morale; Tax compliance; Tax experiment; Life experience;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
学科分类号
摘要
This study reports on the impact of exposure to tax dilemmas on tax morale. We focus on young adults in their “impressionable years” and with little or no previous tax exposure in order to estimate the impact of actual (albeit experimental) exposure to tax dilemmas on their self-declared tax morale. First, we ascertain the participants’ (N = 385), representation and attitudes towards tax, and second, we observe the impact of facing tax decisions on their present and future level of tax compliance. This allows us to investigate, in the realm of taxation, the generic question of knowing how one’s history (and one’s decisions) influences one’s ethical representations and attitude. Although of less external validity than studies using naturally occurring events or historical periods, the use of an experimental simulation enables us to investigate the three different dimensions that could shape people’s personal history: acting, experiencing and observing. Thanks to an interactive and systemic approach, participants are invited to make decisions in a tax context, to experience tax “events” and are given the opportunity to observe both their own behavior, that of others as well as the consequences of those actions, and repeat and test those three different steps several times. We find that the simulation tends to reduce honesty and ethical concerns with respect to taxation, a decrease in tax morale. This reduction seems to be driven by those subjects who were actually facing a tax dilemma and have to make a compliance decision. Other subjects, only observing or experiencing the effects of low tax compliance, are only marginally affected. One possible interpretation is that individuals have an initial overconfidence in their propensity to tax compliance and tax morale, which is challenged by their own decisions in typical dilemmas.
引用
收藏
页码:363 / 397
页数:34
相关论文
共 165 条
  • [31] Feinstein J(1996)Tax knowledge and attitudes towards taxation: a report on a quasi-experiment J Econ Psy 17 387-402
  • [32] Barkworth JM(2006)Clean evidence on peer effects J Lab Econ 24 39-57
  • [33] Murphy K(1999)Gender, exposure to tax knowledge and attitudes towards taxation: an experimental approach J Bus Ethics 18 173-184
  • [34] Becker GS(2002)Altruistic punishment in humans Nature 415 137-46
  • [35] Beer S(1992)Detection probability and taxpayer compliance: a review of the literature J Acc Lit 11 1-116
  • [36] Kasper M(1978)A simulation study of income tax evasion J Public Econ 10 107-528
  • [37] Kirchler E(2020)Social norms moderate the effect of tax system on tax evasion: evidence from a large-scale survey experiment J Bus Ethics 172 727-251
  • [38] Erard B(2003)A very brief measure of the big five personality domains J R Personal 37 504-100
  • [39] Bicchieri C(1991)Shame and embarrassment as deterrents to noncompliance with the law: the case of an anti-littering campaign Env and Behav 23 233-144
  • [40] Xiao E(1998)An examination of ethical standards for tax issues J Acc Ed 16 85-205