Are electronic cigarettes a healthier alternative to conventional tobacco smoking?

被引:0
作者
Jan Löhler
Barbara Wollenberg
机构
[1] Wissenschaftliches Institut für angewandte HNO-Heilkunde (WIAHNO,
[2] Scientific Institute of Applied ENT Medicine) of the Deutscher Berufsverband der HNO-Ärzte e. V. (German Professional Association of ENT Surgeons),undefined
[3] Schleswig-Holstein University Hospital,undefined
[4] Lübeck Campus,undefined
[5] ENT Clinic,undefined
来源
European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology | 2019年 / 276卷
关键词
Electronic nicotine delivery systems; e-Cigarette; Risks; Head and neck cancer; Ingredients; Gateway hypothesis; Smoking; Smoking cessation; Review;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
学科分类号
摘要
Electronic cigarettes (EC) with and without nicotine are used by more and more consumers within the last decade. The long-term risks of vapor inhalation are unknown. This study should describe the state of the art of knowledge with respect to the following four items: (1) ingredients of the vapor and their potential risks, the influence of EC on smoking of combustible tobacco to (2) adults and (3) the youth, and (4) the side effects of passive vaping. The vapor of EC contains, in comparison to tobacco smoke, less harmful substances, qualitatively and quantitatively. But, due to failing standardization of EC, this comparison is difficult. Adults are often using both, EC and combustible cigarettes dually. In addition, EC were used for supporting smoke-quitting. Unfortunately, consuming EC with and without nicotine due later to a higher risk of conventional tobacco smoking for the user. In general, the effects of passive vaporing are unknown. Although the vapor of EC is less harmful than tobacco smoke, EC are not hazard-free lifestyle products. Technical standardization should be desirable. Adult smoker’s benefit using EC is given by completely change to EC only. The rates of success using EC for smoke quitting are not well evaluated. Children and their parents should be informed on the risks of EC use as a precursor of combustible smoking mandatorily. Internet selling EC to any non-adult should be forbidden by law. EC ought not to be allowed to weaken non-smoker’s rights, and third persons should be protected by the potential hazards of EC vaporing.
引用
收藏
页码:17 / 25
页数:8
相关论文
共 122 条
  • [1] Ernst A(1889)On the etymology of the word tobacco Am Anthropologist A 2 133-142
  • [2] Müller FH(1940)Tabakmißbrauch und Lungencarcinom Zeitschrift für Krebsforschung 49 57-365
  • [3] Lickint F(1929)Tabak und Tabakrauch als ätiologischer Faktor des Carcinoms Zeitschrift für Krebsforschung 30 349-79
  • [4] Proctor RN(1999)Why did the Nazis have the world’s most aggressive anti-cancer campaign? Endeavour 23 76-748
  • [5] Doll R(1950)Smoking and carcinoma of the lung BMJ 2 739-242
  • [6] Hill AB(2004)Mortality in relation to smoking: 50 years’ observations on male British doctors BMJ 328 1519-137
  • [7] Doll R(2016)Drug vaping Toxics 4 29-139
  • [8] Peto R(2018)the use of tobacco, E-cigarettes, and methods to quit smoking in Germany. A representative study using 6 waves of data over 12 months (the DEBRA study) Dtsch Arztebl Int 115 235-734
  • [9] Boreham J(2017)E-Shishas und E-Zigaretten, Umsätze weisen steil nach oben Dtsch Arztebl 114 A68-142
  • [10] Sutherland I(2017)E-Shishas und E-Zigaretten: debatte um Schaden und Nutzen Dtsch Arztebl 114 A70-595