Weak Keys in MST1

The public key cryptosystem MST1 has been introduced by Magliveras et al. [12] (Public Key Cryptosystems from Group Factorizations. Jatra Mountain Mathematical Publications). Its security relies on the hardness of factoring with respect to wild logarithmic signatures. To identify ‘wild-like’ logarithmic signatures, the criterion of being totally-non-transversal has been proposed. We present tame totally-non-transversal logarithmic signatures for the alternating and symmetric groups of degree ≥ 5. Hence, basing a key generation procedure on the assumption that totally-non-transversal logarithmic signatures are ‘wild like’ seems critical. We also discuss the problem of recognizing ‘weak’ totally-non-transversal logarithmic signatures, and demonstrate that another proposed key generation procedure based on permutably transversal logarithmic signatures may produce weak keys.