Cosmopolitanism: Sovereignty denied or sovereignty restated?

被引:0
作者
Mikkel Thorup
机构
[1] Institute of Philosophy and the History of Ideas,
[2] University of Aarhus,undefined
来源
International Politics | 2010年 / 47卷
关键词
cosmopolitanism; sovereignty; globalization; war; humanitarian intervention;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
学科分类号
摘要
This article explores and criticizes key assumptions of contemporary cosmopolitanism, not least the notion of post-sovereignty, trying to understand how the cosmopolitan power and sovereignty critique may be very compatible with present-day reconfigurations and relegitimizations of state power and sovereignty. Through a critique of how cosmopolitans sketch out a problematic nation state's past and a more factual efficient and morally appropriate post-nation state condition the article claims that cosmopolitanism may come to serve as legitimizing cover for a new sovereigntist language and practice wielded by the same powers who were dominant in the nation state age, namely the Western states. The purpose of the article is to ask whether cosmopolitanism and humanitarianism have become the new sovereigntist language uniting state officials and state-critical scholars?
引用
收藏
页码:659 / 679
页数:20
相关论文
共 15 条
  • [1] Beck U(2001)Redefining power in the global age: Eight theses Dissent 48 83-89
  • [2] Booth K(1995)Human wrongs and international relations International Affairs 71 103-126
  • [3] Canovan M(1998)Crusaders, sceptics and the nation Journal of Political Ideologies 3 237-250
  • [4] Dillon M(2000)Global governance, liberal peace, and complex emergency Alternatives 25 117-143
  • [5] Reid J(1997)Democracy and globalization Global Governance 3 251-267
  • [6] Held D(1998)The end of the old order? Globalization and the prospects for world order Review of International Studies 24 219-243
  • [7] Held D(2000)Europe at the millennium Politics 20 55-62
  • [8] McGrew A(2003)American power: From ‘compellance’ to cosmopolitanism? International Affairs 79 1-22
  • [9] Kaldor M(2001)World citizenship vs. state sovereignty. Decisionism, political theory and the possibility of democracy without a state Distinktion 2 101-114
  • [10] Kaldor M(2003)Human rights as geopolitics. Carl Schmitt and the legal forms of American supremacy Cultural Critique 54 120-147