The causal explanatory functions of medical diagnoses

被引:0
作者
Hane Htut Maung
机构
[1] Lancaster University,Department of Politics, Philosophy, and Religion
来源
Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics | 2017年 / 38卷
关键词
Diagnosis; Explanation; Causation; Mechanisms;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
学科分类号
摘要
Diagnoses in medicine are often taken to serve as explanations of patients’ symptoms and signs. This article examines how they do so. I begin by arguing that although some instances of diagnostic explanation can be formulated as covering law arguments, they are explanatory neither in virtue of their argumentative structures nor in virtue of general regularities between diagnoses and clinical presentations. I then consider the theory that medical diagnoses explain symptoms and signs by identifying their actual causes in particular cases. While I take this to be largely correct, I argue that for a diagnosis to function as a satisfactory causal explanation of a patient’s symptoms and signs, it also needs to be supplemented by understanding the mechanisms by which the identified cause produces the symptoms and signs. This mechanistic understanding comes not from the diagnosis itself, but rather from the theoretical framework within which the physician operates.
引用
收藏
页码:41 / 59
页数:18
相关论文
共 48 条
  • [1] Rzepiński Tomasz M(2007)The structure of diagnosis in medicine: Introduction to interrogative characteristics Theoretical Medicine and Bioethics 28 63-81
  • [2] Stanley Donald E(2013)The logic of medical diagnosis Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 56 300-315
  • [3] Campos Daniel G(1989)Models of explanation and explanation in medicine International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 3 199-212
  • [4] Qiu Ren-Zong(2014)Causal explanatory pluralism and medically unexplained physical symptoms Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 20 928-933
  • [5] Cournoyea Michael(1981)What is diagnosis? Some critical reflections Metamedicine 2 319-329
  • [6] Kennedy Ashley G(2004)Explaining medically unexplained symptoms Canadian Journal of Psychiatry 49 663-671
  • [7] Whitbeck Caroline(1959)Reasoning foundations of medical diagnosis Science 130 9-21
  • [8] Kirmayer Laurence J(1975)The diagnostic process as a statistical-causal analysis Theory and Decision 6 57-86
  • [9] Groleau Danielle(1994)Causal reasoning and the diagnostic process Theoretical Medicine 15 315-333
  • [10] Looper Karl J(2013)Philosophy of science and the diagnostic process Family Practice 30 501-505