Science, God and Ockham’s razor

被引:0
作者
David H. Glass
机构
[1] University of Ulster,School of Computing and Mathematics
来源
Philosophical Studies | 2017年 / 174卷
关键词
Explaining away; Ockham’s razor; Bayesian reasoning; Atheism;
D O I
暂无
中图分类号
学科分类号
摘要
In discussions about the existence of God, it is sometimes claimed that the progress of science has removed the need for God. This paper uses a Bayesian analysis of Ockham’s razor to formulate and evaluate this argument, which is referred to as the science explains away God argument (SEAGA). Four different strategies for responding to this argument are presented and evaluated. It is argued that one of these strategies highlights how difficult it is to show that the conditions for applying Ockham’s razor are satisfied and hence why SEAGA is very unlikely to succeed.
引用
收藏
页码:1145 / 1161
页数:16
相关论文
共 48 条
[41]   The Reasons of Atheists and Agnostics for Nonbelief in God's Existence Scale: Development and Initial Validation [J].
Bradley, David F. ;
Exline, Julie J. ;
Uzdavines, Alex ;
Stauner, Nick ;
Grubbs, Joshua B. .
PSYCHOLOGY OF RELIGION AND SPIRITUALITY, 2018, 10 (03) :263-275
[42]   Nothingness or a God: Nihilism, Enlightenment, and "Natural Reason" in Friedrich Heinrich Jacobi's Works [J].
Maftei, Stefan-Sebastian .
META-RESEARCH IN HERMENEUTICS PHENOMENOLOGY AND PRACTICAL PHILOSOPHY, 2013, 5 (02) :279-297
[43]   Thomas Aquinas and Francisco Suarez in Francisco de Quevedo's Providence of God Treaty [J].
Kruse, Elisabeth .
ESPIRITU, 2023, 72 (165) :139-153
[45]   From Aristotelianism to Galilean science: Paolo Sarpi's natural philosophy [J].
Baldin, Gregorio .
INTELLECTUAL HISTORY REVIEW, 2022, 32 (02) :179-196
[46]   THE RELEVANCE OF HUME'S NATURAL HISTORY OF RELIGION FOR COGNITIVE SCIENCE OF RELIGION [J].
De Cruz, Helen .
RES PHILOSOPHICA, 2015, 92 (03) :653-674
[47]   Data and debate in science and faith: exploring and extending Ecklund's research programme [J].
Astley, Jeff .
JOURNAL OF BELIEFS & VALUES-STUDIES IN RELIGION & EDUCATION, 2021, 42 (02) :243-253
[48]   Barrett's cognitive science of religion vs. theism & atheism: a compatibilist approach [J].
Morris, Heather .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY AND THEOLOGY, 2020, 81 (04) :386-403