This study examined the effects on teachers’ expectations of including information about students’ intrapersonal and interpersonal strengths in vignettes of Latino English Language Learner (ELL) and Caucasian non-ELL students in U.S. schools. Ninety-one elementary school teachers read one of four randomly assigned fictional vignettes describing a student struggling in school and then predicted the student’s future outcomes. Descriptions of student strengths (present vs. absent) and ethnic and linguistic backgrounds (Latino ELL vs. Caucasian non-ELL) were manipulated. Significant findings were obtained for the effects of including strengths on teachers’ expectations for both student groups in a variety of domains, including short- and long-term academic and behavioral outcomes, and level of family involvement in the child’s education. Implications for consideration of strengths in comprehensive assessments of children are discussed.