A systematic review on the role of language-related factors in the manifestation of stuttering in bilinguals

被引:12
作者
Chaudhary, Chanchal [1 ]
Maruthy, Santosh [2 ]
Guddattu, Vasudeva [3 ]
Krishnan, Gopee [1 ]
机构
[1] Manipal Acad Higher Educ, Manipal Coll Hlth Profess, Dept Speech & Hearing, Manipal 576104, Karnataka, India
[2] All India Inst Speech & Hearing, Dept Speech Language Sci, Mysore 570006, Karnataka, India
[3] Manipal Acad Higher Educ, Prasanna Sch Publ Hlth, Dept Data Sci, Manipal 576104, Karnataka, India
关键词
Stuttering; Bilingualism; Language; Language dominance; Language proficiency; PHONETIC COMPLEXITY; ENGLISH; DOMINANCE; CHILDREN; SPEECH; DISFLUENCY;
D O I
10.1016/j.jfludis.2021.105829
中图分类号
R36 [病理学]; R76 [耳鼻咽喉科学];
学科分类号
100104 ; 100213 ;
摘要
Purpose: Bilingual(s) who stutter (BWS) provide an opportunity to explore the link between stuttering and language. Unlike in monolinguals, stuttering in bilinguals could be influenced by both speaker-related language (e.gs. dominance & proficiency) and linguistic typology-related factors (e.g., structure of languages). However, the available literature is largely inconclusive on these factors. In this context, we systematically reviewed the literature to compile evidence on the influence of such factors on BWS. Method: We followed the conventional systematic review process that included five databases. Further, the quality of the included articles was assessed using Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) for quality rating. Result: Thirteen articles passed the selection criteria. Review of these articles revealed that language proficiency and dominance are the important factors that affect stuttering frequency in BWS. Though the linguistic typology is portrayed as a factor on the differential manifestation of dysfluencies in both languages of the BWS, the literature does not provide substantiating data for this. Further, the lack of uniformity in assessing and reporting language dominance and proficiency are the major drawbacks in the existing literature on stuttering in BWS. Conclusion: This review identifies proficiency and dominance as the major factors that influence the stuttering frequency in BWS. Currently, the evidence for the influence of typological differences between languages of the BWS on stuttering largely remains whimsical. Future research shall employ the recommended tasks and metrics while assessing the dysfluencies in BWS so that findings across centres become comparable, which in turn, could yield valid inferences.
引用
收藏
页数:16
相关论文
共 63 条
[1]   Phonetic complexity and stuttering in Arabic [J].
Al-Tamimi, Feda ;
Khamaiseh, Zaidan ;
Howell, Peter .
CLINICAL LINGUISTICS & PHONETICS, 2013, 27 (12) :874-887
[2]   Patterns of stuttering in a Spanish/English bilingual: A case report [J].
Ardila, Alfredo ;
Ramos, Eliane ;
Barrocas, Robert .
CLINICAL LINGUISTICS & PHONETICS, 2011, 25 (01) :23-36
[3]   Attention and inhibition in bilingual children: evidence from the dimensional change card sort task [J].
Bialystok, E ;
Martin, MM .
DEVELOPMENTAL SCIENCE, 2004, 7 (03) :325-339
[4]   Reshaping the Mind: The Benefits of Bilingualism [J].
Bialystok, Ellen .
CANADIAN JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY-REVUE CANADIENNE DE PSYCHOLOGIE EXPERIMENTALE, 2011, 65 (04) :229-235
[5]   Dominance and Age in Bilingualism [J].
Birdsong, David .
APPLIED LINGUISTICS, 2014, 35 (04) :374-392
[6]   Stuttering prevalence, incidence and recovery rates depend on how we define it: Comment on Yairi & Ambrose' article Epidemiology of stuttering: 21st century advances [J].
Brocklehurst, Paul H. .
JOURNAL OF FLUENCY DISORDERS, 2013, 38 (03) :290-293
[7]   The Loci of Stutterings In The Speech Sequence [J].
Brown, Spencer F. .
JOURNAL OF SPEECH DISORDERS, 1945, 10 (03) :181-192
[8]   Developing and Using Big Data Archives to Quantify Disfluency and Stuttering in Bilingual Children [J].
Brundage, Shelley B. ;
Corcoran, Tayler ;
Wu, Catherine ;
Sturgill, Charlotte .
SEMINARS IN SPEECH AND LANGUAGE, 2016, 37 (02) :117-127
[9]  
Carias S., 2006, Journal of Multilingual Communication Disorders, V4, P149, DOI [DOI 10.1080/14769670601092663, 10.1080/14769670601092663]
[10]   Physiological indices of bilingualism: Oral-motor coordination and speech rate in Bengali-English speakers [J].
Chakraborty, Rahul ;
Goffman, Lisa ;
Smith, Anne .
JOURNAL OF SPEECH LANGUAGE AND HEARING RESEARCH, 2008, 51 (02) :321-332