Universality of the energy-containing structures in wall-bounded turbulence

The scaling behaviour of the longitudinal velocity structure functions <(delta(r)u)(2p)>(1/p) (where 2p represents the order) is studied for various wall-bounded turbulent flows. It has been known that for very large Reynolds numbers within the logarithmic region, the structure functions can be described by <(delta(r)u)(2p)>(1/p)/U-tau(2) D-p ln(r/z) + E-p (where r is the longitudinal distance, z the distance from the wall, U-tau the friction velocity and D-p, E-p are constants) in accordance with Townsend's attached eddy hypothesis. Here we show that the ratios D-p/D-1 extracted from plots between structure functions - in the spirit of the extended self-similarity hypothesis - have further reaching universality for the energy containing range of scales. Specifically, we confirm that this description is universal across wall-bounded flows with different flow geometries, and also for both the longitudinal and transversal structure functions, where previously the scaling has been either difficult to discern or differences have been reported when examining the direct representation of <(delta(r)u)(2p)>(1/p). In addition, we present evidence of this universality at much lower Reynolds numbers, which opens up avenues to examine structure functions that are not readily available from high Reynolds number databases.