A systematic review and meta-analysis comparing adverse events and functional outcomes of different pouch designs after restorative proctocolectomy

被引:23
作者
Simillis, C. [1 ,2 ]
Afxentiou, T. [1 ]
Pellino, G. [1 ]
Kontovounisios, C. [1 ,2 ]
Rasheed, S. [2 ]
Faiz, O. [3 ]
Tekkis, P. P. [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Chelsea & Westminster Hosp NHS Fdn Trust, Dept Colorectal Surg, London, England
[2] Imperial Coll, Dept Surg & Canc, London, England
[3] St Marks Acad Inst, Surg Epidemiol Trials & Outcomes Ctr, London, England
关键词
Restorative proctocolectomy; ileal pouch-anal anastomosis; pouch design; meta-analysis; PELVIC ILEAL RESERVOIRS; LONG-TERM OUTCOMES; QUALITY-OF-LIFE; ULCERATIVE-COLITIS; ANAL ANASTOMOSIS; MUCOSAL PROCTECTOMY; ILEOANAL ANASTOMOSIS; CONTROLLED-TRIAL; S-ILEAL; COMPLICATIONS;
D O I
10.1111/codi.14104
中图分类号
R57 [消化系及腹部疾病];
学科分类号
摘要
AimThere is no consensus as to which ileoanal pouch design provides better outcomes after restorative proctocolectomy. This study compares different pouch designs. MethodA systematic review of the literature was performed. A random effects meta-analytical model was used to compare adverse events and functional outcome. ResultsThirty comparative studies comparing J, W, S and K pouch designs were included. No significant differences were identified between the different pouch designs with regard to anastomotic dehiscence, anastomotic stricture, pelvic sepsis, wound infection, pouch fistula, pouch ischaemia, perioperative haemorrhage, small bowel obstruction, pouchitis and sexual dysfunction. The W and K designs resulted in fewer cases of pouch failure compared with the J and S designs. J pouch construction resulted in a smaller maximum pouch volume compared with W and K pouches. Stool frequency per 24h and during daytime was higher following a J pouch than W, S or K constructions. The J design resulted in increased faecal urgency and seepage during daytime compared with the K design. The use of protective pads during daytime and night-time was greater with a J pouch compared to S or K. The use of antidiarrhoeal medication was greater after a J reservoir than a W reservoir. Difficulty in pouch evacuation requiring intubation was higher with an S pouch than with W or J pouches. ConclusionDespite its ease of construction and comparable complication rates, the J pouch is associated with higher pouch failure rates and worse function. Patient characteristics, technical factors and surgical expertise should be considered when choosing pouch design.
引用
收藏
页码:664 / 675
页数:12
相关论文
共 63 条
  • [1] [Anonymous], 2013, Assessing risk of bias in included studies
  • [2] [Anonymous], DIS COLON RECTUM
  • [3] Pouch design and long-term functional outcome after ileal pouch-anal anastomosis
    Block, M.
    Borjesson, L.
    Lindholm, E.
    Oresland, T.
    [J]. BRITISH JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 2009, 96 (05) : 527 - 532
  • [4] CLINICAL AND PHYSIOLOGICAL STUDY OF ANAL-SPHINCTER AND ILEAL-J POUCH BEFORE PREILEOSTOMY CLOSURE AND 6 AND 12 MONTHS AFTER CLOSURE OF LOOP ILEOSTOMY
    CHAUSSADE, S
    MICHOPOULOS, S
    HAUTEFEUILLE, M
    VALLEUR, P
    HAUTEFEUILLE, P
    GUERRE, J
    COUTURIER, D
    [J]. DIGESTIVE DISEASES AND SCIENCES, 1991, 36 (02) : 161 - 167
  • [5] PROCTOCOLECTOMY AND ILEOANAL ANASTOMOSIS WITH J-SHAPED OR S-SHAPED ILEAL POUCH
    COHEN, Z
    MCLEOD, RS
    [J]. WORLD JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 1988, 12 (02) : 164 - 168
  • [6] METAANALYSIS IN CLINICAL-TRIALS
    DERSIMONIAN, R
    LAIRD, N
    [J]. CONTROLLED CLINICAL TRIALS, 1986, 7 (03): : 177 - 188
  • [7] CLINICAL AND FUNCTIONAL OUTCOME AFTER RESTORATIVE PROCTOCOLECTOMY
    DESILVA, HJ
    DEANGELIS, CP
    SOPER, N
    KETTLEWELL, MGW
    MORTENSEN, NJM
    JEWELL, DP
    [J]. BRITISH JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 1991, 78 (09) : 1039 - 1044
  • [8] Long-term functional outcome and quality of life after stapled restorative proctocolectomy
    Fazio, VW
    O'Riordain, MG
    Lavery, IC
    Church, JM
    Lau, P
    Strong, SA
    Hull, T
    [J]. ANNALS OF SURGERY, 1999, 230 (04) : 575 - 584
  • [9] ILEAL POUCH-ANAL ANASTOMOSES COMPLICATIONS AND FUNCTION IN 1005 PATIENTS
    FAZIO, VW
    ZIV, Y
    CHURCH, JM
    OAKLEY, JR
    LAVERY, IC
    MILSOM, JW
    SCHROEDER, TK
    [J]. ANNALS OF SURGERY, 1995, 222 (02) : 120 - 127
  • [10] Quantification of risk for pouch failure after ileal pouch anal anastomosis surgery
    Fazio, VW
    Tekkis, PP
    Remzi, F
    Lavery, IC
    Manilich, E
    Connor, J
    Preen, M
    Delaney, CP
    [J]. ANNALS OF SURGERY, 2003, 238 (04) : 605 - 614