Surgery or Radiotherapy of the Primary Tumor in T1-2 Head and Neck Squamous Cell Carcinoma with Resectable N3 Nodes: A Multicenter GETTEC Study

被引:3
作者
Carsuzaa, Florent [1 ]
Thariat, Juliette [2 ]
Gorphe, Philippe [3 ]
Righini, Christian [4 ]
Cosmidis, Alain [5 ]
Thureau, Sebastien [6 ]
Roge, Maximilien [6 ]
De Mones, Erwan [7 ]
Servagi-Vernat, Stephanie [8 ]
Tonnerre, Denis [1 ]
Moriniere, Sylvain [9 ]
Dugas, Amaury [10 ]
Malard, Olivier [11 ]
Pasquier, Francois [11 ]
Vergez, Sebastien [12 ]
Salleron, Julia [13 ]
Dufour, Xavier [1 ]
机构
[1] CHU Poitiers, ENT, Serv ORL Chirurg Cervicomaxillofaciale & Audiopho, Poitiers, France
[2] Ctr Francois Baclesse ARCHADE, Radiotherapy, Caen, France
[3] Univ Paris Saclay, Dept Head & Neck Oncol, Gustave Roussy, Villejuif, France
[4] CHU Grenoble, ENT, La Tronche, France
[5] CHU Lyon, ENT, Lyon, France
[6] Ctr Henri Becquerel, Radiotherapy, Rouen, France
[7] CHU Bordeaux Pellegrin, ENT, Bordeaux, France
[8] Ctr Jean Godinot, Radiotherapy, Reims, France
[9] CHU Tours, ENT, Tours, France
[10] CHU Caen, ENT, Caen, France
[11] CHU Nantes, ENT, Nantes, France
[12] CHU Toulouse, Inst Univ Canc Toulouse Oncopole, ENT, Toulouse, France
[13] Univ Lorraine, Cellule Data Biostat, Inst Cancerol Lorraine, Vandoeuvre Les Nancy, France
关键词
LOCALLY ADVANCED HEAD; SEVERE LATE TOXICITY; INDUCTION CHEMOTHERAPY; CONCURRENT CHEMORADIOTHERAPY; DEFINITIVE RADIOTHERAPY; HYPOPHARYNGEAL CANCER; NODAL METASTASES; DISSECTION; OUTCOMES; MANAGEMENT;
D O I
10.1245/s10434-019-07589-0
中图分类号
R73 [肿瘤学];
学科分类号
100214 ;
摘要
Background The prognosis of advanced nodal (N3) squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck (HNSCC) is poor. We investigated whether surgery or radiotherapy of early (T1-2) primary stage HSNCC is preferable to limit the overall morbidity after upfront neck dissection (uND) for N3 disease. Methods This retrospective multicentric Groupe d'etude des Tumeurs de la Tete Et du Cou study included patients undergoing uND and surgery or radiotherapy of their primary. Prognostic factors were evaluated using propensity score matching to account for biases in performing surgery depending on primary site and stage. Results Of 189 T1-2, N3 HNSCC patients, 70 (37.0%) underwent uND: 42 with surgery of their primary and 28 with radiotherapy only. Radiotherapy alone was more frequent in patients with hypopharyngeal primaries. All local (N = 3) and regional (N = 10) relapses (included 2 locoregional relapses) occurred within the first 2 years. There were 16 distant metastatic failures. Five-year locoregional relapse and survival incidences were 15.7% and 66.5% and were similar regardless of the treatment of the primary. The overall morbidity rate was 65.2% and was similar after weighting by the inverse propensity score (p = 0.148). The only prognostic factor for morbidity was the radicality of the uND. Prolonged parenteral feeding was not more frequent in patients only irradiated to their primary (p = 0.118). Prolonged tracheostomy was more frequent after surgery of the primary. Conclusions In patients with T1-2, N3 HNSCC undergoing uND, radiotherapy and surgery of the primary yield similar oncological outcomes. Morbidity was related to the extent of neck dissection.
引用
收藏
页码:3673 / 3680
页数:8
相关论文
共 33 条
[1]   Node-positive hypopharyngeal cancer treated by (chemo)radiotherapy: Impact of up-front neck dissection on outcome, toxicity, and quality of life [J].
Al-Mamgani, Abrahim ;
Meeuwis, Cees A. ;
van Rooij, Peter H. ;
Mehilal, Robert ;
Basdew, Harie ;
Sewnaik, Aniel ;
Levendag, Peter C. .
HEAD AND NECK-JOURNAL FOR THE SCIENCES AND SPECIALTIES OF THE HEAD AND NECK, 2013, 35 (09) :1278-1286
[2]   Neck dissection in the combined-modality therapy of patients with locoregionally advanced head and neck cancer [J].
Argiris, A ;
Stenson, KM ;
Brockstein, BE ;
Mittal, BB ;
Pelzer, H ;
Kies, MS ;
Jayaram, P ;
Portugal, L ;
Wenig, BL ;
Rosen, FR ;
Haraf, DJ ;
Vokes, EE .
HEAD AND NECK-JOURNAL FOR THE SCIENCES AND SPECIALTIES OF THE HEAD AND NECK, 2004, 26 (05) :447-455
[3]   Outcomes of Patients with N3 Neck Nodes Treated with Chemoradiation [J].
Ballonoff, Ari ;
Raben, David ;
Rusthoven, Kyle E. ;
Bassetti, Michael ;
Kane, Madeleine ;
Song, John I. ;
Chen, Changhu .
LARYNGOSCOPE, 2008, 118 (06) :995-998
[4]   Treatment outcome of N3 nodal head and neck squamous cell carcinoma [J].
Chan, SW ;
Mukesh, BN ;
Sizeland, A .
OTOLARYNGOLOGY-HEAD AND NECK SURGERY, 2003, 129 (01) :55-60
[5]   Therapeutic options in patients with early T stage and advanced N stage of tonsillar squamous cell carcinomas [J].
Chung, Man Ki ;
Son, Young-Ik ;
Cho, Jae Keun ;
So, Yoon Kyoung ;
Woo, Seung Hoon ;
Jeong, Han-Sin ;
Baek, Chung-Hwan .
OTOLARYNGOLOGY-HEAD AND NECK SURGERY, 2010, 143 (06) :808-814
[6]   Phase III Randomized Trial of Induction Chemotherapy in Patients With N2 or N3 Locally Advanced Head and Neck Cancer [J].
Cohen, Ezra E. W. ;
Karrison, Theodore G. ;
Kocherginsky, Masha ;
Mueller, Jeffrey ;
Egan, Robyn ;
Huang, Chao H. ;
Brockstein, Bruce E. ;
Agulnik, Mark B. ;
Mittal, Bharat B. ;
Yunus, Furhan ;
Samant, Sandeep ;
Raez, Luis E. ;
Mehra, Ranee ;
Kumar, Priya ;
Ondrey, Frank ;
Marchand, Patrice ;
Braegas, Bettina ;
Seiwert, Tanguy Y. ;
Villaflor, Victoria M. ;
Haraf, Daniel J. ;
Vokes, Everett E. .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL ONCOLOGY, 2014, 32 (25) :2735-+
[7]   N2-N3 neck nodal control without planned neck dissection for clinical/radiologic complete responders - Results of Trans Tasman Radiation Oncology Group study 98.02 [J].
Corry, June ;
Peters, Lester ;
Fisher, Richard ;
Macann, Andrew ;
Jackson, Michael ;
McClure, Bev ;
Rischin, Danny .
HEAD AND NECK-JOURNAL FOR THE SCIENCES AND SPECIALTIES OF THE HEAD AND NECK, 2008, 30 (06) :737-742
[8]   Split therapy: Planned neck dissection followed by definitive radiotherapy for a T1, T2 pharyngolaryngeal primary cancer with operable N2, N3 nodal metastases - A prospective study [J].
D'Cruz, AK ;
Pantvaidya, GH ;
Agarwal, JP ;
Chaukar, DA ;
Pathak, KA ;
Deshpande, MS ;
Pai, PS ;
Chaturvedi, P ;
Dinshaw, KA .
JOURNAL OF SURGICAL ONCOLOGY, 2006, 93 (01) :56-61
[9]   Does clinical and radiological response predict complete tumor control in N2-N3 squamous cell head and neck cancer after non-operative management of the neck? [J].
Dequanter, Didier ;
Lothaire, Philippe ;
Awada, Ahmad ;
Lalami, Yassine ;
Nguyen, Thi Hien ;
Lemort, Marc ;
Vandevelde, Luc ;
Andry, Guy .
ACTA OTO-LARYNGOLOGICA, 2006, 126 (11) :1225-1228
[10]   Outcomes in Advanced Head and Neck Cancer Treated with Up-front Neck Dissection prior to (Chemo)Radiotherapy [J].
Elicin, Olgun ;
Albrecht, Tobias ;
Haynes, Alan G. ;
Bojaxhiu, Beat ;
Nisa, Lluis ;
Caversaccio, Marco ;
Dal Pra, Alan ;
Schmuecking, Michael ;
Aebersold, Daniel M. ;
Giger, Roland .
OTOLARYNGOLOGY-HEAD AND NECK SURGERY, 2016, 154 (02) :300-308