Radical vs. Local Excision in Rectal Carcinoma T1N0M0: Recurrence and Mortality Rates

被引:1
作者
Khalid, Aisha [1 ,2 ]
Aloul, Zaina [3 ]
Chouhan, Hanumant [4 ]
机构
[1] Harvard Med Sch, Res, Boston, MA 02115 USA
[2] Alfred, Cardiothorac Surg, Melbourne, Vic, Australia
[3] Cardiff Univ, Gen Surg, Cardiff, Wales
[4] Monash Hlth, Colorectal Surg, Melbourne, Vic, Australia
关键词
t1nomo; survival; recurrence; apr; tems; localised rectal carcinoma; TRANSANAL ENDOSCOPIC MICROSURGERY; COLORECTAL-CANCER; SURGERY; T1; RESECTION; ADENOCARCINOMA;
D O I
10.7759/cureus.25433
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Local transanal excision of early rectal carcinoma is an appealing treatment because of its low morbidity rates and better functional results than radical resection. However, this treatment approach is controversial due to its association with local recurrence when compared to the latter. This review aims to compare the local recurrence and mortality rates of local vs. radical excision in patients with T1N0M0 rectal carcinoma, based on data in the literature in the last 20 years. A PubMed, Cochrane, and Goggle Scholar search of published literature in the last 20 years was performed. A total of 12 studies were identified. Three were prospective, one was a population-based propensity matching study, one was a nationwide cohort study, one was a meta-analysis, and the remaining studies were retrospective/observational. The mean local recurrence rate within five years from the studies selected for local excision (LE: 12.8%) was nearly double that of radical excision (RAD: 5.0%). The five-year mean survival rate for both LE and RAD groups from the studies selected was 86%, which was equal for both groups. The main predictors of poor outcomes were older age and the presence of two or more comorbid conditions. There is a consensus amongst studies that LE is associated with inferior oncological outcomes such as postoperative complications and recurrence when compared to RAD. The higher local recurrence rates in LE are attributed to occult lymph node disease and inadequate adjunctive therapy due to suboptimal staging. There is no difference in the five-year survival rate when compared to RAD. A longer follow-up period is needed to determine whether the survival rates diverge after five years.
引用
收藏
页数:5
相关论文
共 18 条
[1]  
Albert M, 2019, SHACKELFORDS SURG AL, P1992
[2]   T1 adenocarcinoma of the rectum - Transanal excision or radical surgery? [J].
Bentrem, DJ ;
Okabe, S ;
Wong, WD ;
Guillem, JG ;
Weiser, MR ;
Temple, LK ;
Ben-Porat, LS ;
Minsky, BD ;
Cohen, AM ;
Paty, PB .
ANNALS OF SURGERY, 2005, 242 (04) :472-479
[3]   Long-term oncological outcomes of local excision versus radical resection for early colorectal cancer in young patients without preoperative chemoradiotherapy: a population-based propensity matching study [J].
Cao, Bin ;
Min, Li ;
Zhu, Shengtao ;
Shi, Haiyun ;
Zhang, Shutian .
CANCER MEDICINE, 2018, 7 (06) :2415-2422
[4]  
Celen O, 2004, NEOPLASMA, V51, P487
[5]   Transanal excision vs. major surgery for T1 rectal cancer [J].
Endreseth, BH ;
Myrvold, HE ;
Romundstad, P ;
Hestvik, UE ;
Bjerkeset, T ;
Wibe, A .
DISEASES OF THE COLON & RECTUM, 2005, 48 (07) :1380-1388
[6]   Immediate radical resection after local excision of rectal cancer: An oncologic compromise? [J].
Hahnloser, D ;
Wolff, BG ;
Larson, DW ;
Ping, J ;
Nivatvongs, S .
DISEASES OF THE COLON & RECTUM, 2005, 48 (03) :429-437
[7]   Transanal endoscopic microsurgery: a review [J].
Heidary, Behrouz ;
Phang, Terry P. ;
Raval, Manoj J. ;
Brown, Carl J. .
CANADIAN JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 2014, 57 (02) :127-138
[8]   Local Resection Compared With Radical Resection in the Treatment of T1N0M0 Rectal Adenocarcinoma: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis [J].
Kidane, Biniam ;
Chadi, Sami A. ;
Kanters, Steve ;
Colquhoun, Patrick H. ;
Ott, Michael C. .
DISEASES OF THE COLON & RECTUM, 2015, 58 (01) :122-140
[9]   Transanal endoscopic microsurgery and radical surgery for T1 and T2 rectal cancer - Retrospective study [J].
Lee, W ;
Lee, D ;
Choi, S ;
Chun, H .
SURGICAL ENDOSCOPY AND OTHER INTERVENTIONAL TECHNIQUES, 2003, 17 (08) :1283-1287
[10]   Recurrence after transanal excision of T1 rectal cancer: Should we be concerned? [J].
Madbouly, KM ;
Remzi, FH ;
Erkek, BA ;
Senagore, AJ ;
Baeslach, CM ;
Khandwala, F ;
Fazio, VW ;
Lavery, IC .
DISEASES OF THE COLON & RECTUM, 2005, 48 (04) :711-719