Attitudes of Mexican geneticists towards prenatal diagnosis and selective abortion

被引:0
|
作者
Carnevale, A
Lisker, R
Villa, AR
Armendares, S
机构
[1] Inst Nacl Pediat, Directora Gen, Mexico City 04530, DF, Mexico
[2] Inst Nacl Nutr, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
[3] Univ Nacl Autonoma Mexico, Inst Invest Antropol, Mexico City, DF, Mexico
来源
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICAL GENETICS | 1998年 / 75卷 / 04期
关键词
genetic counselling; prenatal diagnosis; fetal abnormality;
D O I
10.1002/(SICI)1096-8628(19980203)75:4<426::AID-AJMG16>3.0.CO;2-Q
中图分类号
Q3 [遗传学];
学科分类号
071007 ; 090102 ;
摘要
Prenatal diagnosis (PD) provides the physician information on whether the unborn fetus has a genetic or chromosomal disorder, and offers patients a new option: selective abortion. In the present study, we analyzed the answers Mexican geneticists provided to a few selected questions from a multinational survey designed by Wertz and Fletcher [1988: Am J Hum Genet 42:592-600]. The selected questions were related to the use of PD, the acceptance of selective abortion, and the self-reported directiveness of counselling following the diagnosis of a fetal anomaly. Our results show that the great majority of Mexican geneticists participating in the study agree with PD when medically indicated, but not on free demand. Specific cases stimulated the group on thinking more than the general statements provided in the survey. Although the majority agreed that PD should be available to all women, when faced with cases of nonmorbid maternal anxiety, paternity testing, and sex selection, the proportion of geneticists willing to perform the test decreased substantially. When counselling patients on a fetal anomaly, the minority would be as unbiased as possible, and this seems to be the tendency in developing countries where counselling, as stated in the respondents' comments, reflects the belief that the goal of genetics is the prevention of or opposition to abortion. Counselling was influenced by the severity of the disorder. The geneticists' personal attitude toward abortion in the same situations was stronger than when counselling others. Analysis of directiveness in counselling for fetal anomaly showed that older geneticists, with more years of experience in medical genetics, were more likely to be neutral. When counselling directively, the group showed an overall direction toward continuing affected pregnancies. However, older geneticists and those with more than 10 years of practice were more likely than their younger counterparts to counsel towards terminating affected pregnancies. In personal situations of fetal disorder, the general tendency was to abort; however, geneticists seeing more than 5 patients per week, and those who believe that religion is important, were more likely to reject abortion. The sample is representative of Mexican geneticists and the main limitation of this study is that the geneticists have very little experience in PD, and that their responses were mostly based on theory. However, their opinions may influence the demand and the availability of PD and abortion, as well as the possibility of legalization of abortion on the basis of a fetal defect. (C) 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.
引用
收藏
页码:426 / 431
页数:6
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Abortion attitudes of pregnant women in prenatal care
    Learman, LA
    Drey, EA
    Gates, EA
    Kang, MS
    Washington, AE
    Kuppermann, M
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF OBSTETRICS AND GYNECOLOGY, 2005, 192 (06) : 1939 - 1945
  • [32] HUSBANDS ATTITUDES TOWARDS ABORTION AND CANADIAN ABORTION LAW
    OSBORN, RW
    SILKEY, B
    JOURNAL OF BIOSOCIAL SCIENCE, 1980, 12 (01) : 21 - 30
  • [33] Predictive and prenatal diagnosis of Huntington's disease:: Attitudes of Mexican neurologists, psychiatrists, and psychologists
    Vilatela, MEA
    Morales, AO
    de la Cadena, CG
    López, IR
    Aranda, CM
    Villa, A
    ARCHIVES OF MEDICAL RESEARCH, 1999, 30 (04) : 320 - 324
  • [34] Prenatal Diagnosis and Abortion Are Not in Conflict in Israel
    Zivotofsky, Ari Z.
    Jotkowitz, Alan
    AMERICAN JOURNAL OF BIOETHICS, 2009, 9 (08): : 58 - 60
  • [35] Attitudes towards abortion in the Danish population
    Norup, M
    BIOETHICS, 1997, 11 (05) : 439 - 449
  • [36] CONSULTANT GYNECOLOGISTS AND ATTITUDES TOWARDS ABORTION
    CHAMBERLAIN, A
    JOURNAL OF BIOSOCIAL SCIENCE, 1980, 12 (04) : 407 - 415
  • [37] Changing attitudes towards abortion in Europe
    Arisi, E
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF CONTRACEPTION AND REPRODUCTIVE HEALTH CARE, 2003, 8 (02): : 109 - 121
  • [38] COUNSELING NEEDS AND ATTITUDES TOWARD PRENATAL-DIAGNOSIS AND ABORTION IN FRAGILE-X FAMILIES
    MERYASH, DL
    ABUELO, D
    CLINICAL GENETICS, 1988, 33 (05) : 349 - 355
  • [39] Attitudes of Saudi parents with a deaf child towards prenatal diagnosis and termination of pregnancy
    Alsulaiman, Ayman
    Mousa, Ahmed
    Kondkar, Altaf A.
    Abu-Amero, Khaled K.
    PRENATAL DIAGNOSIS, 2014, 34 (02) : 153 - 158
  • [40] ATTITUDES OF WOMEN OF CHILDBEARING AGE TOWARDS PRENATAL-DIAGNOSIS IN SOUTHEASTERN FRANCE
    JULIANREYNIER, C
    MACQUARTMOULIN, G
    MOATTI, JP
    LOUNDOU, A
    AURRAN, Y
    CHABAL, F
    AYME, S
    PRENATAL DIAGNOSIS, 1993, 13 (07) : 613 - 627