Ethical issues about the paradigm shift in the treatment of children with trisomy 18

被引:23
作者
Silberberg, Agustin [1 ]
Robetto, Josefina [2 ]
Grimaux, Guadalupe [3 ]
Nucifora, Laura [4 ]
Moreno Villares, Jose Manuel [5 ]
机构
[1] Univ Austral, Hosp Univ Austral, Dept Bioeth, Av Juan Peron 1500,Ex Ruta 234,B1629AHJ Pilar, Buenos Aires, DF, Argentina
[2] Univ Austral, Fac Ciencias Biomed, Chair Pathophysiol, Buenos Aires, DF, Argentina
[3] Univ Austral, Fac Ciencias Biomed, Dept Bioeth, Buenos Aires, DF, Argentina
[4] Univ Austral, Fac Ciencias Biomed, Buenos Aires, DF, Argentina
[5] Clin Univ Navarra, Dept Pediat, Madrid, Spain
关键词
Ethics; Trisomy; 18; Palliative care; Quality of life; Interventionist approach; INFANTS; INTERVENTION; MANAGEMENT; DECISIONS; ATTITUDES; SURVIVAL; SURGERY; CARE;
D O I
10.1007/s00431-019-03531-4
中图分类号
R72 [儿科学];
学科分类号
100202 ;
摘要
Until recently, trisomy 18 was considered a disease incompatible with life, with a high percentage of electively terminated pregnancies. The usual behavior was denial of treatment. But some medical interventions have changed the survival of children. A search for articles published in the PubMed database on the latest medical decisions in newborns with trisomy 18 was done. Two main subjects were examined: (1) the chances of survival and (2) the perception of quality of life. Trisomy 18 is no longer considered a disease incompatible with life, and the discussion has shifted towards the type of treatment that is appropriate to initiate at birth. There are two medical attitudes towards these children: either palliative care or life-prolonging interventions. With medical intervention, the survival is as high as 23% at 5 years of age. Regarding the quality of life, all decision-makers emphasize the possibility of taking the child home. The physicians' perception is more pessimistic than that of the parents. Only a few children benefit from medical interventions. Conclusion: There is a rethinking of treatment behavior in children with trisomy 18. The possible quality of life achieved should be further investigated. It seems inappropriate to simply dismiss medical interventions.What is Known center dot Until recently, trisomy 18 was considered a disease incompatible with life. The most common behavior was abortion and denial of treatment.What is New center dot It is no longer considered a lethal disease. The type of medical intervention that is appropriate to perform is now being discussed. Selected children benefit from an interventionist approach.
引用
收藏
页码:493 / 497
页数:5
相关论文
共 33 条
[1]   Ethical dilemmas associated with clinicians' decisions about treatment in critically ill infants born in Cordoba, Argentina [J].
Alfredo Silberberg, Agustin ;
Eduardo Gallo, Juan .
JOURNAL OF CHILD HEALTH CARE, 2017, 21 (01) :121-126
[2]   Flaws in the assessment of the best interests of the newborn [J].
Bellieni, Carlo V. ;
Buonocore, Giuseppe .
ACTA PAEDIATRICA, 2009, 98 (04) :613-617
[3]  
Carey JC, 2009, PEDIATRICS, V123, pE547, DOI 10.1542/peds.2008-3729
[4]  
Crawford Doreen, 2016, Nurs Child Young People, V28, P17, DOI 10.7748/ncyp.28.7.17.s18
[5]  
Derrington Sabrina F, 2011, J Clin Ethics, V22, P338
[6]   Moving toward a shared process: The impact of parent experiences on perinatal palliative care [J].
Hasegawa, Susan L. ;
Fry, Jessica T. .
SEMINARS IN PERINATOLOGY, 2017, 41 (02) :95-100
[7]   Differences in Perspective on Prognosis and Treatment of Children with Trisomy 18 [J].
Hurley, Edward H. ;
Krishnan, Sankaran ;
Parton, Lance A. ;
Dozor, Allen J. .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICAL GENETICS PART A, 2014, 164 (10) :2551-2556
[8]   Trisomy 18: A survey of opinions, attitudes, and practices of neonatologists [J].
Jacobs, Adam P. ;
Subramaniam, Akila ;
Tang, Ying ;
Philips, Joseph B., III ;
Biggio, Joseph R. ;
Edwards, Rodney K. ;
Robin, Nathaniel H. .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICAL GENETICS PART A, 2016, 170 (10) :2638-2643
[9]   Parental Hopes, Interventions, and Survival of Neonates With Trisomy 13 and Trisomy 18 [J].
Janvier, Annie ;
Farlow, Barbara ;
Barrington, Keith J. .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF MEDICAL GENETICS PART C-SEMINARS IN MEDICAL GENETICS, 2016, 172 (03) :279-287
[10]   Cardiac surgery for children with trisomies 13 and 18: Where are we now? [J].
Janvier, Annie ;
Farlow, Barbara ;
Barrington, Keith .
SEMINARS IN PERINATOLOGY, 2016, 40 (04) :254-260