Comparative phenotype mapping of normal vs. malignant pediatric B-lymphopoiesis unveils leukemia-associated aberrations

Leukemic cells of B-lineage acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) are regarded as the malignant counterparts of immature, physiologic B cell precursors (BCPs). To determine whether phenotypic differences exist between these corresponding cell types, we investigated samples of normal pediatric bone marrow (n=30) as well as of B-precursor ALL at diagnosis (n=53; common and pre-B subtype). Using three-color multiparameter flow cytometric analysis, we compared the leukemic populations with the physiologic BCPs of corresponding maturity with respect to the intensity with which they expressed a series of antigens. In some of these antigens, leukemia-associated aberrations were frequently observed. In particular, overexpression of CD10 was displayed by 65% of ALL samples, whereas 58% of leukemic cases aberrantly exhibited very low or no CD45RA expression. Regarding CD11a and CD44, 47% and 35% of ALL populations were aberrant as defined by either the absence or significant overexpression of the antigen. In contrast, antigen densities of CD49d, CD49e, and CD99 on leukemic cells were in the normal range of values for BCPs. Combining the patterns of frequently aberrant markers in a comprehensive analysis, we were able to identify individual phenotypic leukemic cell aberrations in up to 98% of investigated cases. CD10 and/or CD45RA were aberrant in 86% of cases overall, emphasizing the high discriminative potential of these two markers. Using comparative phenotype mapping based on quantitatively aberrant, leukemia-associated antigenic patterns, we were able to detect leukemic blasts among normal bone marrow cells at frequencies as low as 10(-5). We speculate that our approach may have a profound impact on the development of new strategies for minimal residual disease investigations in patients with BCP-ALL.