What understanding of economics do medical students have?

被引:3
作者
Spura, Anke [1 ,2 ]
Werwick, Katrin [3 ]
Robra, Bernt-Peter [2 ]
Stallmann, Christoph [2 ]
March, Stefanie [2 ]
Ladebeck, Nadine [4 ]
Braun-Dullaeus, Ruediger [5 ]
Stieger, Philipp [5 ]
机构
[1] Continuiing Educ Qualificat Univ Cooperat, Fed Ctr Hlth Educ, Unit 2 24, Maarweg 149-161, D-50825 Cologne, Germany
[2] Otto von Guericke Univ, Inst Social Med & Hlth Econ, Magdeburg, Germany
[3] Otto von Guericke Univ, Med Fac, Off Study Dean, Magdeburg, Germany
[4] Hsch Magdeburg Stendal, FB Soziale Arbeit Gesundheit & Medien, Magdeburg, Germany
[5] Univ Hosp Magdeburg, Univ Clin Cardiol & Angiol, Magdeburg, Germany
关键词
health economics; economization; medical education; medical students; qualitative research; HEALTH-CARE-SYSTEM; LICENSING REGULATIONS; PUBLIC-HEALTH; PATIENT;
D O I
10.3205/zma001249
中图分类号
G40 [教育学];
学科分类号
040101 ; 120403 ;
摘要
Introduction: Economic topics appear in the medical studies curriculum at different times. Despite socio-political relevance, there is hardly any information about the degree of understanding that medical students have of "economics in medicine". The present study addresses the questions: What understanding of "economics in medicine" do medical students have before the start of the Practical Year? To what extent is economic teaching content understood as "economization" from outside the profession? Method: Magdeburg medical students in the 5th year of study, who participated in preparatory seminars for the Practical Year (PY) in 2014 and 2015 (60 participants each), assessed the relevance of various seminar topics four months prior to the start of the semester. On the basis of a three-stage qualitative-reconstructive partial evaluation, students' economic understanding is explored through secondary analysis: 1. deductive derivation of the analysis units; 2. integrative basic method ("segmentation", "micro-linguistic detailed analysis", "central theme"); 3. development of a theoretical model by placing the central themes in context following Grounded Theory. Results: Based on the theory, 19 free-text answers with economic reference were identified from the total of all free-text answers. Each answer was assigned to at least one of a total of six themes of the students' understanding of economics: 1. de-professionalizing economization, 2. deciding and working economically, 3. ambivalent requirements for efficiency and equity, 4. the doctor as an entrepreneur, 5. economics as relevant learning content, 6. PY as a conflict-laden setting for economized working and learning. The theoretical model contains social, praxeological and professional references, which can themselves be ambivalent and conflicting. Conclusion: Despite their critical attitude, the surveyed medical students are neither hostile to economics nor do they regard economics in medicine as a taboo subject. Economic learning content is recognized as relevant. Educational formats that tackle the tension between patient and system orientation in a problem-oriented manner can be a productive setting for economic reflection.
引用
收藏
页数:9
相关论文
共 50 条
[31]   What do female medical students know about planned oocyte cryopreservation and what are their personal attitudes? [J].
Armstrong, Austin G. ;
Woods, Maggie ;
Keomany, Jennifer ;
Grainger, David ;
Shah, Shriya ;
Pavone, MaryEllen .
JOURNAL OF ASSISTED REPRODUCTION AND GENETICS, 2023, 40 (6) :1305-1311
[32]   Asking future doctors: what support options do medical students want to cope with medical school? [J].
E. Ehring ;
T. Frese ;
S. Fuchs ;
K. Dudo ;
L. Pukas ;
D. Stoevesandt ;
S. Watzke .
Journal of Public Health, 2023, 31 :115-122
[33]   Indications of medical plants: what do medical students in Germany know? A cross-sectional study [J].
Buentzel, Soren Klaus ;
Ritschel, Maria-Louisa ;
Wurm-Kuczera, Rebecca ;
Buentzel, Judith .
JOURNAL OF CANCER RESEARCH AND CLINICAL ONCOLOGY, 2022, 148 (11) :3175-3182
[34]   Indications of medical plants: what do medical students in Germany know? A cross-sectional study [J].
Sören Klaus Büntzel ;
Maria-Louisa Ritschel ;
Rebecca Wurm-Kuczera ;
Judith Büntzel .
Journal of Cancer Research and Clinical Oncology, 2022, 148 :3175-3182
[35]   Asking future doctors: what support options do medical students want to cope with medical school? [J].
Ehring, E. ;
Frese, T. ;
Fuchs, S. ;
Dudo, K. ;
Pukas, L. ;
Stoevesandt, D. ;
Watzke, S. .
JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH-HEIDELBERG, 2023, 31 (01) :115-122
[36]   What do medical students think about conscientious objection? A cross-sectional study from Turkey [J].
Civaner, M. Murat ;
Yalcinkaya, Eylul ;
Macdonald, Arlene .
BMC MEDICAL EDUCATION, 2025, 25 (01)
[37]   What medical students with better academic results do: a cross-sectional analysis [J].
Urrizola, Amaia ;
Santiago, Raul ;
Gea, Alfredo ;
Rubio, Sandra ;
Vilalta-Lacarra, Anna ;
Rodriguez, Javier ;
Arbea, Leire .
BMC MEDICAL EDUCATION, 2023, 23 (01)
[38]   Recognizing that it is part and parcel of what they do: teaching palliative care to medical students in the UK [J].
Gibbins, J. ;
McCoubrie, R. ;
Maher, J. ;
Wee, B. ;
Forbes, K. .
PALLIATIVE MEDICINE, 2010, 24 (03) :299-305
[39]   How and what do medical students learn in clerkships? Experience based learning (ExBL) [J].
Dornan, Tim ;
Tan, Naomi ;
Boshuizen, Henny ;
Gick, Rachel ;
Isba, Rachel ;
Mann, Karen ;
Scherpbier, Albert ;
Spencer, John ;
Timmins, Elizabeth .
ADVANCES IN HEALTH SCIENCES EDUCATION, 2014, 19 (05) :721-749
[40]   Medical students’ experience of emotions and success in neurological studies – What do they tell us? [J].
Hanna Ansakorpi ;
Marja-Liisa Sumelahti ;
Raimo Kaasila .
BMC Medical Education, 17