Variability in the prioritization of patients for cataract extraction

被引:7
作者
Garcia Gutierrez, Susana [1 ]
Bilbao, Amaia [2 ]
Maria Beguiristain, Jose [3 ]
Navarro, Gemma [4 ]
Martinez Tapias, Jesus [5 ]
Antonio Blasco, Juan [6 ]
Maria Quintana, Jose [1 ]
机构
[1] Hosp Galdakao Usansolo CIBERESP, Unidad Invest, Galdakao, Bizkaia, Spain
[2] CIBERESP, Fdn Vasca Innovac & Invest Sanit BIOEF, Sondika, Bizkaia, Spain
[3] Direcc Territorial Sanidad, San Sebastian, Gipuzkoa, Spain
[4] Corp Parc Tauli, Unidad Epidemiol Clin, Barcelona, Spain
[5] Hosp Univ Virgen Nieves, Subdirecc Med Invest Calidad & Docencia, Granada, Spain
[6] Agencia Lain Entralgo, Unidad Evaluac Tecnol Sanit, Madrid, Spain
关键词
cataract extraction; prioritization; waiting list; variability; WAITING-TIMES; PRIORITY CRITERIA; SURGERY; INDEX; VF-14;
D O I
10.1093/intqhc/mzq002
中图分类号
R19 [保健组织与事业(卫生事业管理)];
学科分类号
摘要
The aim of this study was to compare time spent waiting for cataract extraction across various hospitals and to determine if it was influenced by severity of disease or patient characteristics. Ambispective cohort study. Clinical, sociodemographic, and health-related quality of life data were collected along with time spent on the waiting list. Twelve hospitals in four regions of Spain. A total of 4043 patients who were waiting for being intervened on cataracts in the participant centres were recruited prospectively. Priority was assigned retrospectively using a previously validated scoring system. Time spent on waiting list. Statistically significant differences in time spent on the waiting list (P < 0.0001) were observed across the hospitals, even after adjusting for pathology, age, social dependency, laterality of the cataract and number of inappropriate interventions in each centre. Waiting time was not correlated with preintervention visual acuity, preintervention visual function measured by the VF-14 or priority score. Allocation of cataract surgery does not appear to be correlated with the need for surgery or the likely benefit to be derived from it in the Spanish participant centres. The use of explicit and standardized priority criteria could provide a fairer, more rational way to manage waiting lists for this procedure and may help to reduce unnecessary variation on access to health care.
引用
收藏
页码:107 / 114
页数:8
相关论文
共 21 条
[1]   International applicability of the VF-14 - An index of visual function in patients with cataracts [J].
Alonso, J ;
Espallargues, M ;
Anderson, TF ;
Cassard, SD ;
Dunn, E ;
BernthPetersen, P ;
Norregaard, JC ;
Black, C ;
Steinberg, EP ;
Anderson, GF .
OPHTHALMOLOGY, 1997, 104 (05) :799-807
[2]  
Ballan L, 2001, CAN MED ASSOC J, V164, P1177
[3]   Changes in waiting lists over time [J].
Bellan, Lorne .
CANADIAN JOURNAL OF OPHTHALMOLOGY-JOURNAL CANADIEN D OPHTALMOLOGIE, 2008, 43 (05) :547-550
[4]   ROBUST LOCALLY WEIGHTED REGRESSION AND SMOOTHING SCATTERPLOTS [J].
CLEVELAND, WS .
JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN STATISTICAL ASSOCIATION, 1979, 74 (368) :829-836
[5]   A systematic literature review of the evidence on benchmarks for cataract surgery waiting time [J].
Conner-Spady, Barbara ;
Sanmartin, Claudia ;
Sanmugasunderam, Suren ;
De Coster, Carolyn ;
Lorenzetti, Diane ;
McLaren, Lindsay ;
McGurran, John ;
Noseworthy, Tom .
CANADIAN JOURNAL OF OPHTHALMOLOGY-JOURNAL CANADIEN D OPHTALMOLOGIE, 2007, 42 (04) :543-551
[6]   Patient and physician perspectives of maximum acceptable waiting times for cataract surgery [J].
Conner-Spady, BL ;
Sanmugasunderam, S ;
Courtright, P ;
Mildon, D ;
McGurran, JJ ;
Noseworthy, TW .
CANADIAN JOURNAL OF OPHTHALMOLOGY-JOURNAL CANADIEN D OPHTALMOLOGIE, 2005, 40 (04) :439-447
[7]   Development and assessment of a priority score for cataract surgery [J].
Fantini, MP ;
Negro, A ;
Accorsi, S ;
Cisbani, L ;
Taroni, F ;
Grilli, R .
CANADIAN JOURNAL OF OPHTHALMOLOGY-JOURNAL CANADIEN D OPHTALMOLOGIE, 2004, 39 (01) :48-55
[8]   Validation of priority criteria for cataract extraction [J].
Garcia Gutierrez, Susana ;
Maria Quintana, Jose ;
Bilbao, Amaia ;
Escobar, Antonio ;
Perea Milla, Emilio ;
Elizalde, Belen ;
Bare, Marisa ;
Fernandez de Larrea, Nerea .
JOURNAL OF EVALUATION IN CLINICAL PRACTICE, 2009, 15 (04) :675-684
[9]  
Hadorn David, 2003, J Health Serv Res Policy, V8, P48, DOI 10.1258/13558190360468227
[10]   The New Zealand priority criteria project .1. Overview [J].
Hadorn, DC ;
Holmes, AC .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1997, 314 (7074) :131-134