Population Pharmacokinetic Evaluation with External Validation of Tacrolimus in Chinese Primary Nephrotic Syndrome Patients

Purpose The generalizability of numerous tacrolimus population pharmacokinetic (popPK) models constructed to promote optimal tacrolimus dosing in patients with primary nephrotic syndrome (PNS) is unclear. This study aimed to evaluate the predictive performance of published tacrolimus popPK models for PNS patients with an external data set. Methods We prospectively collected 223 concentrations from 50 Chinese adult patients with PNS who were undergoing tacrolimus treatment. Data on published tacrolimus popPK models for adults and children with PNS were extracted from the literature. Model predictability was evaluated with prediction-based and simulation-based diagnostics and Bayesian forecasting. Results In prediction-based evaluation, none of the 11 identified published popPK models of tacrolimus had met a predefined criteria of a mean prediction error <= +/- 20%, and the prediction error within +/- 30% of the identified models didn't exceed 50%. Simulation-based diagnostics also indicated unsatisfactory predictability. Bayesian forecasting demonstrated amelioration in the model predictability with the inclusion of 2-3 prior observations. Moreover, the predictive performance of nonlinear models was not better than that of one-compartment models. Conclusions The prediction of tacrolimus concentrations for patients with PNS remains challenging; published models are not applicable for extrapolation to other hospitals. Bayesian forecasting significantly improved model predictability and thereby helped to individualize tacrolimus dosing.