Which is the optimum surgical strategy for spondylolisthesis: Reduction or fusion in situ? A meta-analysis from 12 comparative studies

被引:8
|
作者
Jiang, Guangyao [1 ]
Ye, Chenyi [1 ]
Luo, Jianyang [1 ]
Chen, Weishan [1 ]
机构
[1] Zhejiang Univ, Sch Med, Affiliated Hosp 2, Dept Orthoped, 88 Jiefang Rd, Hangzhou 310009, Zhejiang, Peoples R China
基金
中国国家自然科学基金;
关键词
Meta-analysis; Spondylolisthesis; Reduction; Fusion in situ; LUMBAR INTERBODY FUSION; ADULT ISTHMIC SPONDYLOLISTHESIS; INSTRUMENTATION; ARTHRODESIS; ADOLESCENTS; MANAGEMENT;
D O I
10.1016/j.ijsu.2017.04.066
中图分类号
R61 [外科手术学];
学科分类号
摘要
Purpose: To compare the clinical outcomes and complications and radiographic outcomes of the two different surgical strategies (arthrodesis in situ and arthrodesis following reduction) for the surgical management of spondylolisthesis. Methods: After systematic search the PubMed, Ovid MEDLINE, Cochrane, and Embase databases, comparative studies were selected according to eligibility criteria. Checklists by Furlan and by The NewcastleeOttawa quality assessment scale (NOS scale) were used to evaluate the risk of bias of the included randomized clinical trials (RCTs) and nonrandomized controlled studies, respectively. The final strength of evidence was expressed as different levels recommended by the GRADE Working Group. Results: Three RCTs. and nine comparative observational studies were identified. Low-quality evidence indicated that reduction group (RG) was not more effective than fusion in situ group for clinical satisfaction (OR 0.77, 95% CI 0.39-1.54, P = 0.46). and neurologic complication rate (OR 0.89, 95 CI 0.38-2.03, P = 0.78). In secondary outcomes, Low-quality evidence indicated that RG improved fusion rate (OR 2.66, 95% CI 1.15-6.14, P = 0.02). There was no significant difference in the other complication rate (OR 0.89, 95% CI 0.44-1.79, P = 0.63) and blood loss (WMD 14.22, 95% CI -9.53-37.79, P = 0.24) between two groups. Statistical difference was found between the two groups with regard to slipping angle (WMD -6.33, 95% CI -12.60 to -0.06, P = 0.05). Conclusions: There was no definite benefit of reduction over fusion in situ in clinical satisfaction rate and neurologic complication rate. The fusion rate significantly improved while the slipping angle considerably decreased postoperation in reduction group. (C) 2017 Published by Elsevier Ltd on behalf of IJS Publishing Group Ltd.
引用
收藏
页码:128 / 137
页数:10
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Peer review report 1 on "Which is the optimumsurgical strategy for spondylolisthesis: reduction or fusion in situ? A meta-analysis from 12 comparative studies"
    Esposito, Roberto
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SURGERY, 2017, 37 : S326 - S326
  • [3] Surgical management of spondylolisthesis-intentional reduction or in situ fusion: a meta-analysis
    Si, Wenteng
    Xie, Wangcheng
    Feng, Chaobo
    Zhao, Yongzhao
    He, Shisheng
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL MEDICINE, 2019, 12 (08): : 9642 - 9658
  • [4] Fusion in situ versus reduction for spondylolisthesis treatment: grading the evidence through a meta-analysis
    He, Rui
    Tang, Guo-lin
    Chen, Kun
    Luo, Zheng-liang
    Shang, Xifu
    BIOSCIENCE REPORTS, 2020, 40
  • [5] What is the Optimum Fusion Technique for Adult Spondylolisthesis-PLIF or PLF or PLIF Plus PLF? A Meta-analysis From 17 Comparative Studies
    Liu, Xiao-Yang
    Qiu, Gui-Xing
    Weng, Xi-Sheng
    Yu, Bin
    Wang, Yi-Peng
    SPINE, 2014, 39 (22) : 1887 - 1898
  • [6] Clinical effectiveness of reduction and fusion versus in situ fusion in the management of degenerative lumbar spondylolisthesis: a systematic review and meta-analysis
    Wang, Dongfan
    Wang, Wei
    Han, Di
    Muthu, Sathish
    Cabrera, Juan P.
    Hamouda, Waeel
    Ambrosio, Luca
    Cheung, Jason P. Y.
    Le, Hai V.
    Vadala, Gianluca
    Buser, Zorica
    Wang, Jeffrey C.
    Cho, Samuel
    Yoon, S. Tim
    Lu, Shibao
    Chen, Xiaolong
    Diwan, Ashish D.
    EUROPEAN SPINE JOURNAL, 2024, 33 (05) : 1748 - 1761
  • [7] Reduction versus In Situ Fusion for Adult High -Grade Spondylolisthesis: A Systematic Review and Meta -Analysis
    Lak, Asad M.
    Abunimer, Abdullah M.
    Devi, Sharmila
    Chawla, Shreya
    Aydin, Levent
    Tafel, Ian
    Smith, Timothy R.
    Mekary, Rania A.
    Zaidi, Hasan A.
    WORLD NEUROSURGERY, 2020, 138 : 512 - +
  • [8] A Bayesian network meta-analysis of 5 different fusion surgical procedures for the treatment of lumbar spondylolisthesis
    Tang, Linjun
    Wu, Yong
    Jing, Daping
    Xu, Yong
    Wang, Cheng
    Pan, Jingjing
    MEDICINE, 2020, 99 (14)
  • [9] Is reduction better than arthrodesis in situ in surgical management of low-grade spondylolisthesis? A system review and meta analysis
    Bai, Xuedong
    Chen, Jiahai
    Liu, Liyang
    Li, Xiaochuan
    Wu, Yaohong
    Wang, Deli
    Ruan, Dike
    EUROPEAN SPINE JOURNAL, 2017, 26 (03) : 606 - 618
  • [10] Is reduction better than arthrodesis in situ in surgical management of low-grade spondylolisthesis? A system review and meta analysis
    Xuedong Bai
    Jiahai Chen
    Liyang Liu
    Xiaochuan Li
    Yaohong Wu
    Deli Wang
    Dike Ruan
    European Spine Journal, 2017, 26 : 606 - 618