Are Organic Certified Carrots Richer in Health-Promoting Phenolics and Carotenoids than the Conventionally Grown Ones?

The aim of the present study was to determine the concentrations of polyphenols and carotenoids by means of HPLC/UV-Vis in certified organic and non-organic carrots (Daucus carota L.) of two cultivars (Flacoro and Nantejska). The analyzed carrot root samples contained, on average, 4.29 +/- 0.83 mg/100g f.w. of carotenoids (mainly beta-carotene) and 9.09 +/- 2.97 mg/100g f.w. of polyphenols, including 4.44 +/- 1.42 mg/100g f.w. of phenolic acids and 4.65 +/- 1.96 mg/100g f.w. of flavonoids. Significant effects of the production system on the carotenoids (total) and beta-carotene concentration were found, with higher concentrations of these compounds generally identified in conventionally cultivated roots (4.67 +/- 0.88 mg/100g f.w.) vs. organically grown ones (4.08 +/- 0.74 mg/100g f.w.). There was a noticeable inter-sample (inter-farm) variation in the concentration of polyphenols in carrot roots. Despite a general trend towards higher concentrations of these compounds in the organic carrots (9.33 +/- 3.17 mg/100g f.w.) vs. conventional carrots (8.64 +/- 2.58 mg/100g f.w.), and in those of Nantejska (9.60 +/- 2.87 mg/100g f.w.) vs. Flacoro (8.46 +/- 3.02 mg/100g f.w.) cultivar, no consistent, statistically significant impact of the production system and/or cultivar on the level of these bioactive compounds was identified. More efforts should be encouraged to ensure that organic crops reaching the market consistently contain the expected high levels of health-promoting bioactive compounds, which could be brought through their shelf-life and all processing steps, in order to meet consumers' expectations and provide the expected health benefits.