Large discrepancies in differentiation of allozymes, nuclear and mitochondrial DNA loci in recently founded Pacific populations of the pearl oyster Pinctada margaritifera

This study presents a comparative analysis of population structure applied to the pearl oyster (Pinctada margaritifera) from the Central Pacific islands using three classes of molecular markers: two mitochondrial genes (mtDNA), five anonymous nuclear loci (anDNA), and eight polymorphic allozymes. Very low levels of haplotype diversity and nucleotidic divergence detected for mtDNA validate the hypothesis of a recent (re)colonization of Polynesian lagoons after their exondation during the last glaciations. Some nuclear loci, however, showed highly significant F-ST values, indicating a reduced amount of larval exchange between archipelagos at present. A large interlocus variance of F-ST was nevertheless observed. We discuss whether this pattern is inherent to the stochasticity of the drift process since recolonization, or if it could result from balancing selection acting on certain loci. This study illustrates once more the need to combine the analysis of several kinds of loci when unrelated phenomena are likely to leave their footprints on genetic structure.