Performance of 30 commercial SARS-CoV-2 serology assays in testing symptomatic COVID-19 patients

被引：11

作者：

Vauloup-Fellous, Christelle ^{[1
]}

Maylin, Sarah ^{[2
]}

Perillaud-Dubois, Claire ^{[1
]}

Brichler, Segolene ^{[3
,4
]}

Alloui, Chakib ^{[3
,4
]}

Gordien, Emmanuel ^{[3
,4
]}

Rameix-Welti, Marie-Anne ^{[5
,6
]}

Gault, Elyanne ^{[5
,6
]}

Moreau, Frederique ^{[5
,6
]}

Fourati, Slim ^{[7
]}

Challine, Dominique ^{[7
]}

Pawlotsky, Jean-Michel ^{[7
]}

Houhou-Fidouh, Nadhira ^{[8
]}

Damond, Florence ^{[8
]}

Mackiewicz, Vincent ^{[8
]}

Charpentier, Charlotte ^{[8
]}

Meritet, Jean-Francois ^{[9
]}

Rozenberg, Flore ^{[9
]}

Podglajen, Isabelle ^{[10
]}

Marot, Stephane ^{[11
]}

Petit, Heloise ^{[11
]}

Burrel, Sonia ^{[11
]}

Akhavan, Sepideh ^{[11
]}

Leruez-Ville, Marianne ^{[12
]}

Avettand-Fenoel, Veronique ^{[12
]}

Fourgeaud, Jacques ^{[12
]}

Guilleminot, Tiffany ^{[12
]}

Gardiennet, Elise ^{[12
]}

Bonacorsi, Stephane ^{[13
]}

Carol, Agnes ^{[13
]}

Carcelain, Guislaine ^{[14
]}

Villemonteix, Juliette ^{[14
]}

Boukli, Narjis ^{[15
]}

Gozlan, Joel ^{[15
]}

Morand-Joubert, Laurence ^{[15
]}

Legoff, Jerome ^{[2
]}

Delaugerre, Constance ^{[2
]}

Chaix, Marie-Laure ^{[2
]}

Roque-Afonso, Ana-Maria ^{[1
]}

Dortet, Laurent ^{[16
,17
]}

Naas, Thierry ^{[16
,17
]}

Ronat, Jean-Baptiste ^{[16
,17
]}

Lepape, Samuel ^{[1
]}

Marcelin, Anne-Genevieve ^{[11
]}

Descamps, Diane ^{[8
]}

机构：

[1] Univ Paris Saclay, Hop Paul Brousse, AP HP, Virol,Dept Virol,INSERM,U1193, F-94804 Villejuif, France

[2] Univ Paris, Hop St Louis, Dept Agents Infect, Serv Virol,INSERM,UMR 944, Paris, France

[3] Univ Paris Nord, Hop Avicenne, Lab Microbiol Clin, Ctr Natl Reference Hepatites B C & Delta, F-93009 Bobigny, France

[4] Unite INSERM U955, Creteil, France

[5] Univ Paris Saclay, Hop Ambroise Pare, AP HP, Lab Microbiol, Boulogne, France

[6] Univ Versailles St Quentin, Univ Paris Saclay, INSERM, UMR 1173 2I, Versailles, France

[7] Univ Paris Est, Dept Virol, Hop Henri Mondor, Viruses Hepatol Canc Res Unit,INSERM,U955, Creteil, France

[8] Univ Paris, Hop Bichat Claude Bernard, AP HP, Lab Virol,INSERM,UMR 1137,IAME, F-75018 Paris, France

[9] Univ Paris, Hop Cochin, APHP Ctr, Serv Virol, Paris, France

[10] Univ Paris, Hop Europeen Georges Pompidou, APHP Ctr, Serv Virol, Paris, France

[11] Sorbonne Univ, Hop Pitie Salpetriere, AP HP, IPLESP,Lab Virol,INSERM, Paris, France

[12] Univ Paris, Hop Necker, APHP,Inst Cochin, Lab Microbiol Clin,Fac Med,INSERM,U1016,CNRS,UMR, Paris, France

[13] Univ Paris, Hop Robert Debre, Serv Microbiol, Paris, France

[14] Univ Paris, Hop Robert Debre, Lab Immunol, Paris, France

[15] Univ Paris 06, Hop St Antoine, AP HP,Tenon,Trousseau, Dept Virol,Sorbonne Univ,INSERM,UPMC,UMR S 1136,I, Paris, France

[16] Univ Paris Saclay, Serv Bacteriol Hyg, Hop Bicetre, Inserm,U1184, Le Kremlin Bicetre, France

[17] Univ Paris Saclay, LabEx LERMIT, Le Kremlin Bicetre, France

来源：

EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF CLINICAL MICROBIOLOGY & INFECTIOUS DISEASES | 2021年 / 40卷 / 10期

关键词：

Serology; SARS-CoV-2; COVID-19; ANTIBODIES;

D O I：

10.1007/s10096-021-04232-3

中图分类号：

R51 [传染病];

学科分类号：

100401 ;

摘要：

We report evaluation of 30 assays' (17 rapid tests (RDTs) and 13 automated/manual ELISA/CLIA assay (IAs)) clinical performances with 2594 sera collected from symptomatic patients with positive SARS-CoV-2 rRT-PCR on a respiratory sample, and 1996 pre-epidemic serum samples expected to be negative. Only 4 RDT and 3 IAs fitted both specificity (> 98%) and sensitivity (> 90%) criteria according to French recommendations. Serology may offer valuable information during COVID-19 pandemic, but inconsistent performances observed among the 30 commercial assays evaluated, which underlines the importance of independent evaluation before clinical implementation.

引用

页码：2235 / 2241

页数：7

共 19 条

[1] Evaluation of the EUROIMMUN Anti-SARS-CoV-2 ELISA Assay for detection of IgA and IgG antibodies [J].

Beavis, Kathleen G. ;

Matushek, Scott M. ;

Abeleda, Ana Precy F. ;

Bethel, Cindy ;

Hunt, Carlissa ;

Gillen, Stephanie ;

Moran, Angelica ;

Tesic, Vera .

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL VIROLOGY, 2020, 129

[2] Persistence of Anti-SARS-CoV-2 Antibodies in Non-Hospitalized COVID-19 Convalescent Health Care Workers [J].

Bruni, Margherita ;

Cecatiello, Valentina ;

Diaz-Basabe, Angelica ;

Lattanzi, Georgia ;

Mileti, Erika ;

Monzani, Silvia ;

Pirovano, Laura ;

Rizzelli, Francesca ;

Visintin, Clara ;

Bonizzi, Giuseppina ;

Giani, Marco ;

Lavitrano, Marialuisa ;

Faravelli, Silvia ;

Forneris, Federico ;

Caprioli, Flavio ;

Pelicci, Pier Giuseppe ;

Natoli, Gioacchino ;

Pasqualato, Sebastiano ;

Mapelli, Marina ;

Facciotti, Federica .

JOURNAL OF CLINICAL MEDICINE, 2020, 9 (10) :1-14

[3] Detection of 2019 novel coronavirus (2019-nCoV) by real-time RT-PCR (Publication with Expression of Concern) [J].

Corman, Victor M. ;

Landt, Olfert ;

Kaiser, Marco ;

Molenkamp, Richard ;

Meijer, Adam ;

Chu, Daniel K. W. ;

Bleicker, Tobias ;

Bruenink, Sebastian ;

Schneider, Julia ;

Schmidt, Marie Luisa ;

Mulders, Daphne G. J. C. ;

Haagmans, Bart L. ;

van der Veer, Bas ;

van den Brink, Sharon ;

Wijsman, Lisa ;

Goderski, Gabriel ;

Romette, Jean-Louis ;

Ellis, Joanna ;

Zambon, Maria ;

Peiris, Malik ;

Goossens, Herman ;

Reusken, Chantal ;

Koopmans, Marion P. G. ;

Drosten, Christian .

EUROSURVEILLANCE, 2020, 25 (03) :23-30

[4] An evaluation of COVID-19 serological assays informs future diagnostics and exposure assessment [J].

GeurtsvanKessel, Corine H. ;

Okba, Nisreen M. A. ;

Igloi, Zsofia ;

Bogers, Susanne ;

Embregts, Carmen W. E. ;

Laksono, Brigitta M. ;

Leijten, Lonneke ;

Rokx, Casper ;

Rijnders, Bart ;

Rahamat-Langendoen, Janette ;

van den Akker, Johannes P. C. ;

van Kampen, Jeroen J. A. ;

van der Eijk, Annemiek A. ;

van Binnendijk, Rob S. ;

Haagmans, Bart ;

Koopmans, Marion .

NATURE COMMUNICATIONS, 2020, 11 (01)

[5] Critical Care Utilization for the COVID-19 Outbreak in Lombardy, Italy Early Experience and Forecast During an Emergency Response [J].

Grasselli, Giacomo ;

Pesenti, Antonio ;

Cecconi, Maurizio .

JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 2020, 323 (16) :1545-1546

[6] A comparison of four serological assays for detecting anti-SARS-CoV-2 antibodies in human serum samples from different populations [J].

Grzelak, Ludivine ;

Temmam, Sarah ;

Planchais, Cyril ;

Demeret, Caroline ;

Tondeur, Laura ;

Huon, Christele ;

Guivel-Benhassine, Florence ;

Staropoli, Isabelle ;

Chazal, Maxime ;

Dufloo, Jeremy ;

Planas, Delphine ;

Buchrieser, Julian ;

Rajah, Maaran Michael ;

Robinot, Remy ;

Porrot, Francoise ;

Albert, Melanie ;

Chen, Kuang-Yu ;

Crescenzo-Chaigne, Bernadette ;

Donati, Flora ;

Anna, Francois ;

Souque, Philippe ;

Gransagne, Marion ;

Bellalou, Jacques ;

Nowakowski, Mireille ;

Backovic, Marija ;

Bouadma, Lila ;

Le Fevre, Lucie ;

Le Hingrat, Quentin ;

Descamps, Diane ;

Pourbaix, Annabelle ;

Laouenan, Cedric ;

Ghosn, Jade ;

Yazdanpanah, Yazdan ;

Besombes, Camille ;

Jolly, Nathalie ;

Pellerin-Fernandes, Sandrine ;

Cheny, Olivia ;

Ungeheuer, Marie-Noelle ;

Mellon, Guillaume ;

Morel, Pascal ;

Rolland, Simon ;

Rey, Felix A. ;

Behillil, Sylvie ;

Enouf, Vincent ;

Lemaitre, Audrey ;

Creach, Marie-Aude ;

Petres, Stephane ;

Escriou, Nicolas ;

Charneau, Pierre ;

Fontanet, Arnaud .

SCIENCE TRANSLATIONAL MEDICINE, 2020, 12 (559)

[7] Clinical Characteristics of Coronavirus Disease 2019 in China [J].

Guan, W. ;

Ni, Z. ;

Hu, Yu ;

Liang, W. ;

Ou, C. ;

He, J. ;

Liu, L. ;

Shan, H. ;

Lei, C. ;

Hui, D. S. C. ;

Du, B. ;

Li, L. ;

Zeng, G. ;

Yuen, K. -Y. ;

Chen, R. ;

Tang, C. ;

Wang, T. ;

Chen, P. ;

Xiang, J. ;

Li, S. ;

Wang, Jin-lin ;

Liang, Z. ;

Peng, Y. ;

Wei, L. ;

Liu, Y. ;

Hu, Ya-hua ;

Peng, P. ;

Wang, Jian-ming ;

Liu, J. ;

Chen, Z. ;

Li, G. ;

Zheng, Z. ;

Qiu, S. ;

Luo, J. ;

Ye, C. ;

Zhu, S. ;

Zhong, N. .

NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2020, 382 (18) :1708-1720

[8]

Haute Autorite de sante (HAS), 2020, PLAC TESTS SER STRAT, P1

[9]

Huang Angkana T, 2020, Nat Commun, V11, P4704, DOI [10.1101/2020.04.14.20065771, 10.1038/s41467-020-18450-4]

[10] Validation of a commercially available SARS-CoV-2 serological immunoassay [J].

Meyer, B. ;

Torriani, G. ;

Yerly, S. ;

Mazza, L. ;

Calame, A. ;

Arm-Vernez, I ;

Zimmer, G. ;

Agoritsas, T. ;

Stirnemann, J. ;

Spechbach, H. ;

Guessous, I ;

Stringhini, S. ;

Pugin, J. ;

Roux-Lombard, P. ;

Fontao, L. ;

Siegrist, C-A ;

Eckerle, I ;

Vuilleumier, N. ;

Kaiser, L. .

CLINICAL MICROBIOLOGY AND INFECTION, 2020, 26 (10) :1386-1394

← 1 2 →