Correlations Between In Vivo 1H MRS and Ex Vivo 1H HRMAS Metabolite Measurements in Adult Human Gliomas

Purpose: To assess how accurately ex vivo high-resolution magic angle spinning (HRMAS) proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy (H-1 MRS) from small biopsy tissues relate to in vivo H-1 MRS (from larger tumor volumes) in human astrocytomas. Materials and Methods: In vivo (PRESS, TE = 30 msec) and ex vivo (presaturation) H-1 spectra of 17 human astrocytomas (4 grade II. 1 grade III and 12 glioblastomas) were quantified using LCModel. Concentrations of I I metabolites and 2 lipid/macromolecules were retrospectively compared, with histogram analysis of the in vivo MRI data used to evaluate tumor heterogeneity. Results: For homogeneous-appearing tumors, significant correlations were found between in vivo and ex vivo H-1 MRS concentrations of those metabolites known to be metabolically stable in postmortem tissues (eg, creatine, myo-inositol, total cholines, and the approximate to 1.3 and 0.9 ppm lipids). Anaerobic glycolysis during biopsy surgical removal depletes the tissue of glucose, increasing alanine and lactate, and resulted in no correlation between these in vivo and ex vivo metabolite concentrations. Conclusion: Within defined limitations, ex vivo astrocytoma biopsy HRMAS H-1 spectra have similar metabolic profiles to that obtained in vivo and therefore detailed ex vivo characterization of glioma biopsies can directly relate to the original tumor.